We are developing the social individualist meta-context for the future. From the very serious to the extremely frivolous... lets see what is on the mind of the Samizdata people.

Samizdata, derived from Samizdat /n. - a system of clandestine publication of banned literature in the USSR [Russ.,= self-publishing house]

Samizdata quote of the day – How Britain became the place to do business

The ASI published a paper that recommended the wholesale privatization of local government services, starting with bin collection. Thatcher liked it so much that she had it photocopied 10,000 times and sent a copy to every Conservative councillor in Britain.

Thatcher didn’t like the word ‘privatization’, because it sounded new and strange. She wanted to call it denationalisation. But we pointed out that we were going to apply it to industries that had never been nationalised in the first place. We still insisted on spelling it with a ‘z’ to make it look like something new.

The first to go was Cable and Wireless, then BP, but the first big public flotation was of the Post Office telephone service, a state monopoly. Rather than sell it to a private company, the government decided to sell it to everyone, with a flotation in which the public were invited to apply for shares. To keep the telephone workers on side, they were offered 200 free shares if they bought 200. The union ran a hostile campaign showing a telephone cable being cut with scissors, but 96% of the workforce took the money instead.

– Madsen Pirie, recalling how Margaret Thatcher turned things around.

15 comments to Samizdata quote of the day – How Britain became the place to do business

  • Fraser

    ‘The end of all production is consumption.’

    Just to play devils advocate here, I’m not sure that is entirely true in a welfare state. If there is a choice between a failing industry propped up by the government at a cost of £5,000 per employee that also produces some useful goods, is it better to do that than pay that same worker £10,000 in benefits?

    I don’t know, there are upsides and downsides — I suppose it is better for someone to be working that burning cars, and breaking shop windows, but it is also an economic distortion where a competitive industry could profit by using new and better methods, and the fact that the ersatz employee could actually be working somewhere doing something useful.

    The problem is that when the government is so deeply involved in absolutely everything, everything gets screwed up. So much of government policy is putting duct tape on top of a broken system that is held together with glue and breakfast cereal boxes on top of another couple of layers of duct tape. One dumb ass decision leading to a problem, leading to another dumb ass decision leading to another problem, ad infinitum. The fundamental problem of the government’s constant interference is absolutely never the problem that is actually addressed.

    Welfare is a particularly messy problem, which could of course be solved by privatization of welfare (which is to say, private charities.) However, welfare recipients (whether on the dole or in a subsidized industry) have the vote, and it is always easy to cast your vote to spend other people’s money. One need only think of the loudest part of Thatcher’s premiership, namely the miners’ strike to see this subsidized industry thing writ large. The whole thing was just a horrendous mess, and Thatcher’s victory was a turning point in Britain’s fortunes.

    Thatcher was a unique person in British history, looked back on with hatred by the people whose country she saved. To me the worst part of that series The Crown, was Gillian Anderson’s portrayal of Thatcher which was just horrible. She is portrayed almost like Richard the Third, hunchbacked, mean spirited and unpleasant, when she was none of those things. FWIW, her autobiographies are compelling reading.

  • Marius

    The end of all production is consumption.

    Sure. Our ancient ancestors did not hunt and gather for the joy in hunting and gathering, but in order to survive. However, evolution favours those who take an interest in the hunting and the gathering, hence we became a species which needs things to do. We are not lions, happy to doze until hunger spurs us to hunt. Lack of purpose is harmful to humans and this applies to everyone from your ‘Benefits Street’ idlers to Eve Rausing, who ended up barricaded in a few rooms in her husband’s mansions, smoking crack until her heart packed in.

    Elon Musk seems to think that AI + Universal Benefit is the way forward for humanity. I don’t agree.

    @Fraser – we didn’t deserve Maggie. I lose track of the number of muppets still bleating about her, even as they step through the wreckage left by 30 years of destroying her legacy. Early in the new year, British newspapers often publish stories about events from years past, which have emerged from classification under the 30 year rule. Often this includes details of what PMs or others said privately about these matters. It always struck me that, whenever Maggie’s opinion about something was reported, it was almost always spot on. She didn’t always get her own way but her instincts were always right.

  • Lee Moore

    The current problem is not so much that the government is doing things that the private sector could do better and cheaper, though there is some of that (eg schools); but more that (a) the government is doing a lot of stuff that does not need to be done / or positively needs NOT to be done and (c) the government is actively obstructing the private sector from getting on with things that are still in the private sector.

  • Roué le Jour

    The US constitution is a wonderful thing, yet the part of the American political system I am most envious of is the direct election of presidents. If the backbench scum lacked the power to pull the rug out from under her, who knows what Thatcher might have achieved? And how many repugnant leaders might we have been spared who could never have won the popular vote?

  • Martin

    The US constitution is a wonderful thing, yet the part of the American political system I am most envious of is the direct election of presidents. If the backbench scum lacked the power to pull the rug out from under her, who knows what Thatcher might have achieved?

    They wouldn’t have had to rug pull her under an American style system. The term limits would have had her out of office after 1987.

  • Roué le Jour

    Martin,
    Of course, yes. But presidential term limits are fairly recent innovation not mentioned in the constitution. Pity they don’t apply to the various undead members of Congress.

  • Fraser

    @Lee Moore you are exactly right. It is a problem with democratic systems and politics in general. The solution to most problems is the government not doing something or stopping doing something. But “I’m going to do nothing” or “I’m going to shut down this program” is rarely a platform voters like or an activity that alpha, megalomaniacal politicians find suits their persona.

    Plus, as we saw with Doge, shutting down programs is almost impossibly difficult because there are so many grifters and thieves with their hands in the pot. These programs are designed to do enough to make sympathetic victims were it to be shut down even though they are channels to pour money into the pockets of the corrupt and criminal. If Doge did anything it made this abundantly apparent. And to be clear, ever flavor of politician is in on the grift. There are few who can maintain their principles in face of such an avalanche of money. Especially so when their primary opponent is pouring some of that money into attack ads against them.

  • Paul Marks

    There is a difference between contracting-out where the money going to a company comes from taxation, and “privatization” where, if the word means anything at all, the money would come from voluntary contracts with individuals.

    On bin collection – there are now three different bins for homes in my area, and little boxes for “food waste” as well – this is due to insane national regulations. The system is totally mad – and incredibly expensive and inefficient, due to national regulations.

    Contracting out such things as children’s services is a massive con – with “private providers” really being in the business of buying houses (“we have to have somewhere to put the children”) with taxpayer money – houses they (the “private providers”) then own – they treat paying for the houses as “current costs” to be paid for by the taxpayer – that is why a placement for a single child for a year can cost half a million Pounds (“it is not corrupt, because it is legal Councillor Marks – oh you are not on the Council any more ha, ha, ha”).

    As for the denationalisation – coal and steel have almost ceased to exist (their relative decline started before nationalisation – due to union power, under such insane Acts of Parliament as that of 1906, but they continued to decline under state ownership), water is a mess (but then it was a mess under state ownership as well), the railways are a mess (but they have NOT been denationalised – the system is STATE OWNED, yet people talk of the “privatized railways” – delusional, private “operating companies” are not private railways – the two things are utterly different, Japan has private railways, we do NOT – other than a few tourist lines, less than 1% of railways in Britain).

    Telecommications – yes that has been a success.

  • NickM

    I dunno. We still have those Utter Barnabus Blunts of BT Openreach who effectively have a monopoly. I live 13 miles outside of Manchester and have no mobile signal or fibre broadband. Brsk/Youfibre tried… They were either stymied by “Up the Arse With No Reacharound”. Or the fact I live on a street of Biddies and Codgers who still talk about the GPO. We may have something like privatisation (good) in telecoms but we don’t have anything like a free market. Virgin can’t run a cable up here because they aren’t allowed to hang cables but only bury them and the latter isn’t allowed because only Cheshire East Cuntsel has the monopoly to fuck the road up. Which they do, frequently, to keep fat sweaty-arsed cunts in hi-viz jackets. To no good. D’ya want a video of my road? I can do one. It looks like something that would shame Mogadishu. Jesus wouldn’t just have wept, he would have bowked his transverse colon.

  • Paul Marks

    NickM – compared to when the Post Office controlled all telecommunications, the system is much better now.

    As for Britain being “the place to do business” – that is clearly absurd (it is nonsense), but the telecommunications system is better than it was.

    Things were far from perfect in the 1980s – and some decisions made then were terrible mistakes, such the government spending increases (yes it was increased NOT “cut”) and taxation from 1979 to 1982 (Chancellor Howe was useless – and Employment Secretary James Prior was an active menace – he did NOTHING to reduce union power, Mr Prior did not give a damn about rising UNEMPLOYMENT – indeed he was happy that unemployment was increasing, he hoped to use it as a weapon against “Thatcher”, thankfully he was replaced by Norman Tebbit – who did do something about union power – not nearly enough, but something), it was only under Chancellor Nigel Lawson that overall taxation was reduced.

    Nigel Lawson was the only Chancellor to cut taxes, and keep them cut, in my lifetime.

    That, the tax cutting of Chancellor Lawson, was a success – but such things as the “Single European Act” were as disaster – leading to a tidal wave of European Union regulations.

    The “Big Bang” in financial services was a massive con trick – sold as “deregulation” it was really a vast INCREASE in regulation – the state crushed the old voluntary associations, self employed people, and partnership banks, and created an American style “Wall Street” sytem – of a handful of financial corporations joined-at-the-hip with the government (especially the unelected government).

  • Fraser

    @NickM
    I dunno. We still have those Utter Barnabus Blunts of BT Openreach who effectively have a monopoly.

    Try Starlink, and shouldn’t we all get off the ridiculous old telephone network? There are a dozen different voice and video call options that don’t rely on the “natural monopolies” that we seem to be beset with because governments, and even worse, international government agencies, have the imagination and original thinking of a drunk, sleeping fruit fly.

  • NickM

    Fraser,
    Starlink is possible but is expensive (for obvious reasons). I say “possible” when I mean “impossible” because I’d have to cut down trees and that is on a grade II listed property in a “conservation area” and I’d be looking at serious time for that. I mean more time than I’d get for buggering an ossifrage on the War Memorial on Remembrance Sunday. I have, and shall continue to do, “questionable things” but I have my limits.

  • Fraser

    @NickM
    I’d have to cut down trees and that is on a grade II listed property

    Ah, there’s your problem. As if the British government bureaucracy and oppressive planning laws weren’t bad enough, you choose to live in a place with even MORE oppressive planning laws. Near where I live there is a “historical downtown district” where they control what flowers you are allowed in your garden, and what color you can paint your door, and what fixtures you can have in your kitchen. I do not live in the “historical downtown district”.

    Good luck to you, but that is NOT a choice I’d make.

  • Paul Marks

    Fraser – that sounds like the old Realm of Wurttemberg – now part of Baden-Wurttemberg, where the government enforced what your garden should be like, and checked to make sure you kept the inside (yes the inside) of your house clean and tidy – I would have been punished severely for the messy house and garden I have here.

    As for the “Planning Laws” of the United Kingdom – the “free market think tanks” down in London claim they prevent building (they go by the official figures – it never occures to them to use their eyes and go and look at all the houses and flats being built everywhere), and local people hate them because they do NOT prevent developments.

    There is a possible, logical, agreement there – both sides should want to repeal the Planning Laws, however local people keep hopeing they will prevent yet more destruction of woods and fields, or the destruction of treasured old buildings, even when, 99 times out of 100, the Planning Laws fail to do that.

  • Paul Marks

    One thing government could do is to remove Value Added Tax on building repairs – this tax encourages the destruction of beautiful old buildings, and their replacement with ugly (deliberately ugly) new buildings.

    To put such a tax on repairs to buildings (including homes) is utterly mad.

    There are people from all political parties who understand this – I do not know why governments do not get rid of this, utterly insane, tax on building repairs.

    Full disclosure – I have been saying this since the 1980s.

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>