We are developing the social individualist meta-context for the future. From the very serious to the extremely frivolous... lets see what is on the mind of the Samizdata people.

Samizdata, derived from Samizdat /n. - a system of clandestine publication of banned literature in the USSR [Russ.,= self-publishing house]

Samizdata quote of the day – Russia and Britain vastly overestimate each other’s influence

For their part, Russian commentators and politicians today seem to have an absurdly exaggerated idea of Britain’s power, the puppet-masters behind American global domination, still pulling the strings, rather than a country run by naive humanities graduates who place our ‘international standing’ above national interests. Rabid threats to nuke London by tipsy Russian politicians are the last crumbs of dignity and self-respect we have left, for which thank you.

– Ed West

14 comments to Samizdata quote of the day – Russia and Britain vastly overestimate each other’s influence

  • Subotai Bahadur

    Hmmm. If the Russians DO nuke London, will the thousands of Jihadi “migrants” who would be obliterated count as dying to spread Islam and therefore go to Muslim paradise?

    Subotai Bahadur

  • David Roberts

    In a way the Russian commentators and politicians are right, but it is not as they believe. What they are fighting, is not the current British hierarchy. but rather the ideas, ethics and way of politics that Britannia, over the last three centuries, has brought to the world.

  • Nicholas (Pro-Localism) Gray

    I think that when Russian Oligarchs moved to London, the rest of Russia might have thought, “Do they know something we don’t?”

  • george m weinberg

    I have no idea what Russians think, but I’m pretty sure nobody seriously believes Putin has
    any significant influence outside Russia. Pretending to believe it is what is called “virtue signalling”,
    although it doesn’t have anything to do with virtue as the word is usually used.

  • Paul Marks

    The failure of Mr Putin to keep his allow Assad in power in Syria showed the limits of Russian power.

    But was more important was the fiasco of the invasion of Ukraine in 2022 – a plan that made “A Bridge Too Far” look sensible, and carried out with horrible incompetance.

    Britain moved quickly to supply Ukraine with anti tank weapons – but the main reason for the fiasco was the incompetance of the Russian army and many of the senior people (being cronies of Mr Putin) are still in place.

    It is true that the Russian army has learned bitter lessons – even the top brass have learned lessons and are not as useless as they were in 2022, but dead-men-do-not-return-to-life.

    The terrible casualties of the last four years – the slaughter of Russian young men who should have become husbands and fathers, is treason to Russia (the Russian people) by Mr Putin and his cronies – treason of the worst kind, as it may well condemn Russia to demographic extinction (Russia is already relying on the followers of the Crescent Moon – who have been enemies of the Russian people for a thousand years).

    As for Ukraine – it no longer has a real economy, it is totally dependent on foreign aid, and its demographic position is even worse than that of Russia.

    Mr Putin may well have doomed two nations – Ukraine and Russia itself.

    As for the United Kingdom – the position of the United Kingdom, demographically and in every other way, is truly terrible, but that is the fault of its own ruling left-establishment who, for many years, have followed policies that can only lead to the destruction of this nation.

  • Paul Marks

    ally – not allow.

  • Paul Marks

    As for the British, and French, policy of propping up the Ottoman Empire against Russia – this policy dates back to the 1700s, against Catherine the Great’s ideas of destroying the Islamic Empire and restoring Greece (under Russian influnce – of course).

    The Russians of the 18th and 19th centuries believed this showed that the British and French establishments were fake Christians – how else could they support an Islamic Empire which oppressed and slaughterd Christians? Of course, the Russians themselves, even the liberal minded Czar Alexander the Second, were ruthless towards some (some – not all) Muslims – ask a Circassian, the Russians answered Circassian Isamic raiding by either killing or driving out 90%, yes 90%, of the entire Circassian population.

    Alexander the Second finished the process – it is astonishing that the same man who liberated the serfs, and was personally kind and benevolent (even his death showed this – he was in a protected carrage when the leftist attack came, he left the carriage to help other people – that left him exposed to attack, sometimes too much courage is as bad as not having enough courage – Alexander’s action was brave, but foolish) could find no pity in his heart for the Circassians.

    His argument was that pity, mercy, for the enemy population (including women and children) was cruelty to his own people – putting them in danger, if not now – then in the future.

    Someone like that would have reacted rather differently to the October 7th attack – within a week Gaza would have been empty. There would be no people there – they would either have been driven out or killed.

    Sir “Ed” Davey would have a real genocide (rather than his LIE about a genocide) to complain about.

  • but I’m pretty sure nobody seriously believes Putin has any significant influence outside Russia

    You must be joking 😀 Putin has rather a lot of European politicians in his pocket. Do you seriously think European energy policies developed the way they did before 2022 without a major Russia effort?

  • bobby b

    PdH: Are they really “in his pocket”? Or did they simply make really stupid predictions and policy?

    It’s the old malice versus stupidity thing.

  • Fraser

    @bobby b
    It’s the old malice versus stupidity thing.

    Well I think Putin has the malice thing down pretty well, and I think the European leaders are the very essence of stupidity captured in the phrase that is going around “suicidal empathy.”

    Would that Trump was as focused on “Make America Great Again” as Putin is on “Make Russia Great Again”. He might have fucked it up pretty bad with this war, but nobody can doubt that Putin is 100% focused on Russian greatness and doesn’t give a flying fuck about any empathy for anything or anyone non Russian.

  • Paul Marks

    Fraser – the difference between Mr Putin and President Trump is that Mr Putin really did try to win the war in Ukraine but was too incompetant – the insane plan of 2022 was HIS plan.

    President Trump has made no real effort to overthrow the regime in Iran – which has savagely oppressed the Iranian people, and been at war with “death-to-America” United States for 47 years.

    The whole plan of President Trump (and, even more, of J.D. Vance) was “destroy their airforce and navy – kill a few leaders, and then the regime will make a deal to end the development of nuclear weapons”. The Iranian people, and the people of other nations, were always going to be betrayed – there was never any clear objective of liberating them from the IRI regime.

    But the Islamic Republic of Iran regime will NOT make any deal – not a deal they would actually keep. They want nuclear weapons because they want to USE nuclear weapons – and they do not care about being killed, because they believe (sincerly believe) that if they die fighting infidels they will go to paradise and have eternal bliss.

    The United States military could have destroyed the IRI regime (in a couple of weeks – not eight months) – but that was never the plan, the plan was always “talks and deals”.

    Those of us old enough to remember Vietnam remember what a policy of using military pressure to achieve “talks and deals” leads to – it leads to DEFEAT. A regime that could have been destroyed in a few days (and without useing any nuclear weapons at all) emerged the winner (see Admiral Sharp’s book “Strategy for Defeat”).

    It was the same in China – the Communists were being defeated in 1946 (the Manchurian Offensive), but then the “talks and deals” people in Washington intervened.

    Tens of millions of human beings paid with their lives, under the Mao regime, due to the “talks and deals” brigade. And the modern People’s Republic of China regime remains committed to the extermination of liberty everywhere – NOT just in China, and it is more powerful than ever.

    If the objective is not VICTORY, the total destruction of the enemy, then do not bother having a military – just put a pistol in your own mouth and squeeze the trigger, it will save the enemy (such as the IRI regime) killing you later. Ditto your family.

  • Paul Marks

    From the point of view of the midterm elections in the United States – it is not Russia that is pushing up diesel prices to help the Democrats, it is the International Community that is doing so (using the Ukrainians for this purpose) – contrary to the lies of the media, the Straits of Hormuz are NOT closed (there has been no major reduction in the export of hydro-carbons from the Middle East – there are various routes by which hydrocarbons are exported from this area).

    Nor it is Russia that is behind the attack on the Constitution of Poland (including the attack on the President of Poland) – it is the government of Mr Tusk which is a puppet of the European Union and the rest of the accursed International Community. When the Supreme Court is taken over, the Polish Constitution will be a dead letter – and a policy of mass migration (and so on) will be imposed on Poland, leading to the destruction of the Polish nation.

    The same is true of the United States – the Democrats are part of the International Community, and, therefore, they are dedicated to the destruction of the United States as an independent nation – they will do anything (anything) to achieve this objective.

    Mr Putin is a very bad man, a mass murderer, but he is not the main danger to Western nations – including the United Kingdom.

    The main danger to Western nations, to the very existence of Western nations, is the Western establishment.

  • Johnathan Pearce

    I think the original Ed West quote is bang on. It’s what the U.K. has represented over the decades that Putin resents.

    Putin probably burns with rage that M16 got top defectors to give good intel to us in the 1980s, giving the likes of Margaret Thatcher leverage when talking to Gorbachev. That was when the U.K. was still pretty good at this stuff.

    Resentment is what drives many evil people to destroy things. Nietsche wrote about this phenomenon a more than a century ago. Putin is a pathetic man with no friends and a mountain of corpses to show for his life.

  • Paul Marks

    Johnathan Pearce – agreed.

    Mr Putin is responsble for more Russian deaths than any leader since Stalin – the deformed little man Mr Putin admires.

    As for the conflict with the IRI regime – the truth is as follows….

    The Straits of Hormuz are NOT closed (ships go through them every day) – so the media (including supposedly conservative media outlets) are lying. And 26 Americans have been killed since the present campaign started in February.

    26 – not 26 thousand, 26. Every sympathy to the family and friends of the 26 – but that is not a war, that is skirmish.

    However, most voters have a totally false view of the conflict (due to the already mentioned media) – so the midterm elections will be a disaster.

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>