We are developing the social individualist meta-context for the future. From the very serious to the extremely frivolous... lets see what is on the mind of the Samizdata people.
Samizdata, derived from Samizdat /n. - a system of clandestine publication of banned literature in the USSR [Russ.,= self-publishing house]
|
Samizdata quote of the day – Wikipedia: the tragedy of the commons Before 7 October 2023, the English-language Wikipedia article on Zionism opened by describing a movement that emerged to “espouse support for the establishment of a homeland for the Jewish people in Palestine.” Since then, the opening has been reworded to say that this homeland was to be established “through colonization,” immediately followed by a new sweeping claim: “Zionists wanted to create a Jewish state in Palestine with as much land, as many Jews, and as few Palestinian Arabs as possible.” The sentence is backed by an unusually large bundle of 17 citations, drawn from historians including Benny Morris, Rashid Khalidi, Avi Shlaim and Ilan Pappé, and to the casual reader it looks like the settled verdict of scholarship. It is not. The editor who introduced it in August 2024 has since been banned from the entire Palestine-Israel topic area for non-neutral editing. Yet the sentence survives, and for a year Wikipedia formally barred its editors from even discussing whether to remove it.
– Mark Zlochin
|
Who Are We? The Samizdata people are a bunch of sinister and heavily armed globalist illuminati who seek to infect the entire world with the values of personal liberty and several property. Amongst our many crimes is a sense of humour and the intermittent use of British spelling.
We are also a varied group made up of social individualists, classical liberals, whigs, libertarians, extropians, futurists, ‘Porcupines’, Karl Popper fetishists, recovering neo-conservatives, crazed Ayn Rand worshipers, over-caffeinated Virginia Postrel devotees, witty Frédéric Bastiat wannabes, cypherpunks, minarchists, kritarchists and wild-eyed anarcho-capitalists from Britain, North America, Australia and Europe.
|
I mean who uses Wikipedia anymore? Ask Grok, the only AI designed for truth seeking as its primary goal:
Sounds about right.
Wikipedia is pretty good for highly technical subjects and some non recent history, but anything social, recent history or political? Absolute and utter crap. But even for subjects that Wikipedia still retains some credibility for, Grok is better for those too anyway.
One of the two founders of Wikipedia was banned because he resisted its increasing leftist bias – a bias that is general in the education system and the culture generally.
Wikipedia is NOT something that “anyone can edit” – because some people have the power to prevent other people editing, no prizes for guessing the political and cultural opinions of the some-people.
As for Israel…
The largest community in 19th century Jerusalem were (according to the Ottoman Islamic rulers) “Jews”.
Most of the land was desert of malaria filled mashes – the population of the whole area was very small even in the mid 19th century.
There was no policy of driving out Muslims – in spite of the fact that, over the centuries, Jews had been massacred by Muslims again-and-again in the land (yes – the Jews had tried to go back, many times).
There are more Muslims in the land right-now than-there-have-been (certainly vastly MORE than there were in 1948 – and many of those Muslims were from recent immigrant families) – it is the Jews who were driven out of many lands in the Middle East, almost a million of them – Western education systems and the media ignore the destruction, in the 1940s, of Jewish communities in various parts of North Africa and the Middle East that has existed for thousands of years.
It is true that quite a few Muslims left in 1948 (and they have had large families over the last 78 years) – but it was Islamic governments and movements who told them to leave, so they (the Islamic armies) could kill everyone in various areas without the fear they were killing fellow Muslims – the Jews in areas of the land (including “Old Jersualem”) that the Islamic armies captured – were eliminated.
The wild distortions by Western leftists continue – for example the “Economist” magazine now declares that “Opposition Parties” in Israel (after the recent election) should “work with the Arab parties” – by “Arab parties” they do not mean people with darker skin (most Israeli Jews are “Arabs” in this sense) – they mean the Islamic parties – the parties who want to exterminate Israel.
But to admit the nature of most (most – not all) Muslims in Israel is not possible for the “Economist” magazine – because then they might be asked to admit the nature of Islam generally, including the Islamic communities in Britain and the United States.
When given the choice between the truth and their “liberal” (it is not really liberal, Gladstone and John Bright would be disgusted by it, but the establishment call it “liberal”) ideology – the establishment will always choose their ideology.
“Even if it means the death of seven million Jews?” – oh a lot further than that, the establishment will always choose their “liberal” ideology over the truth in France, Germany, Austria, Italy, Britain, the United States – and so on.
“But that means their own children will be murdered or enslaved” – they do not care, their “liberal” ideology is far more important to them than the lives of their children (remember the American parents who come out with the “I love tacos – hate-filled Trump must not be allowed to divide us” speech when their children are murdered, or the German politician who reacted to the rape and murder of his daughter by giving money to a “charity” to bring in MORE rapists and murderers). They must not be “racist” or “Islamophobic” – and if that means their children are murdered or enslaved, that is a price worth paying (in France or Britain – or whereever, including the United States) to avoid being called “racist” or “Islamophobic”.
Even Japan is importing yet more immigrants – indeed Islamic immigrants (“they will just be guest workers” – that LIE has been used before, in Austria, Germany and so on) – so much for electing a “right wing government”.
Expect more “accidental” burnings of Shinto shrines – just like the “accidental” burning of churches on Europe and North America.
And do not turn to the churches to try and preseve Christianity – the “mainstream” churches are fully on board with the “anti racist” “anti Islamophobic” (Muslims can be of any race – but the establishment do not care about such “details”) agenda of the extermination of the West.
Whether it is the King, or the Pope – there is no one to turn to, in order to prevent the destruction of the West. Appeal to them for help – and they will just scream “Racist!” at you.
And elected politicians will not help either – witness the betrayal in Italy and now Japan.
“But President Trump kept his word about immigration” – so he did, but he will be crippled by the new Congress that will be elected on Tuesday and will go into place in January.
I rarely use Wikipedia for anything other than non-political topics. Abs even then it pays to be careful abs double-check.
It doesn’t surprise me that ideological scoundrels use the platform to denounce Israel’s existence. It’s good thing that this is being pointed out.
The poison has gone very deep into people’s heads, and as Paul Marks points out, much of it is the fault of our education system. Another is that Israelphobia/Jew hate has been imported among Muslim immigrants, or their descendants.
I used to value Wikipedia and even made a modest contribution to its request for donations. Then I found out that they already had pots of money. Then I found out that some articles (even a few scientific ones touching on ‘race’ and evolution) had been edited to reflect a political viewpoint.
So now I no longer support Wikipedia. How many times must we say ‘go woke, go broke’?
See the book “Palestina ex Monumentis Veteribus Illustrata”. The book is written in Latin. In 1695. Rilandy was describing what was then called Palestine.
The author Adriani Rilandi is a geographer, cartographer, traveler, philologist, he knew several European languages, Arabic, ancient Greek, Hebrew.
He visited almost 2,500 settlements mentioned in the Bible. The research was conducted as follows:
*He first created the map of Palestine. He then designated every settlement mentioned in the Bible or the Talmud with its original name.
* If the original was Je wi sh, it meant “pasuk” (a suggestion in the Holy Scriptures that mentioned the name. )
* If the original was Roman or Greek, the connection was in Latin or Greek.
In the end, he did a population census by settlements.
Here are the main conclusions and some facts:
* The country is mainly empty, abandoned, sparsely populated, the main population is Jerusalem, Akko, Tsfat, Jaffa, Tveria and Gaza.
* Most of the population is Je w s, almost everyone else is Christians, very few Mu sl ims, mostly Bedo uins.
* The only exception is Nablus (now Shchem), where approximately 120 people from the Mu sl im family Natsha and approximately 70 “shomronims” (Samaritans).
* In Nazareth, the capital of Galilee, lived approximately 700 people – all Christian
In Jerusalem, there were around 5,000 people, mostly Je ws, with a few Christians.
In 1695, it was well-known that the roots of the country were Je wi sh.
There was not a single settlement in Pa le stine with Arabic origins in its name.
Most settlements had Hebrew originals, with some having Greek or Latin origins, which had been adapted into Arabic names that held no meaning in the Arabic language. For example, names like Acre, Haifa, Jaffa, Nablus, Gaza, or Jenin had no philological or historical Arabic roots.
Reland only mentioned Mu sli ms as seasonal agricultural or construction laborers who came to the cities.
In Gaza, around 550 people lived, with half being Je wish and half Christian. Je w s were engaged in successful agriculture, including vineyards, olives, and wheat, while Christians were involved in trade and transportation.
In Tiberias and Safed, Je ws lived, but their occupations were not specified, except for their traditional fishing activities in the Sea of Galilee.
In the village of Umm al-Fahm, there were about ten families, all of whom were Christians (approximately 50 people). There was a small Maronite church in the village.
Reland’s book thoroughly refutes theories about “Pa le stinian traditions” and a “Pal es tinian people” and establishes very little connection between this land and the Arabs, who even adopted the Latin name of the land (Pal es tine) and claimed it as their own.
How does Grok seek truth? I thought that it was only as good as the material upon which it had been trained? Wouldn’t Wiki have been part of that training?
Do Grok and other AI merely seek a consensus view from “reading” all available writings already out there? Or does AI somehow “think” of things more accurately?
I guess at the base I’m asking, will Grok et al. eventually become as inaccurate as Wikipedia?
@bobby b
How does Grok seek truth?
How do you seek truth? By looking at various sources of information and balancing their relative accuracy. But also you learned some basic principles at your mother’s knee (what Freud would have called your super ego.) And these core principles guide your interpretation of these data. We might call it your moral compass.
AI’s also have a “moral compass” in the sense that they are programmed with basic core principles that come not from the data fed to them but as part of the original programming. There is a big controversy for example, right now with Claude, where the Anthropic programmers put in some core rules that prevent Claude from being used to recreate existing video games, and another where there are rules built in to forcibly put watermarking on the text it generates. Claude, which I am mostly positively inclined toward, is beginning to do more of this, and I think it is going to be to their determent.
These core rules are inviolable, or are to some degree, just as your momma taught you to never hit a woman, and treat children with care and kindness. They are built into your core values and no amount of propaganda from the media and other sources will tell you it is ok for dudes with beards and their dick hanging out should be in a ladies locker room.
That is how Grok is programmed with truth seeking. It is open to ideas and doesn’t have these basic politically correct premises at its core.
If you are interested you can read what Grok says about this itself you can read it here.
@Nessimmersion
He visited almost 2,500 settlements mentioned in the Bible.
FWIW, a lot if this is simply not true. It is a meme that has circulated in the Internet for a while, but if you actually look at the contents of the book, which is widely held in high regard, it does not make the census claims, and in fact the author never even visited the Holy Lands, he spent nearly all his life in the Netherlands, but was rather a compiler of data from many other sources. This fact is plain when one considers that for a large amount of recent history it has been part of the Ottoman Empire and consequently dominated by Muslims, and that, during the Crusades, the Crusaders had to displace large armies and populations of Arabs and Muslims.
It is simply the fact that since the Bar Kokhba Revolt and the Roman’s response, when they deliberated decreased the dominance of Judaism in the region followed by its dominance various other Empires, that this area has NOT been dominated by the Jews. A related claim that there is no such thing as a Palestinian is utter crap too. This area has been referred to by variants of that name, including its origins in the Philistines (who were admitted not Arab) since a thousand years before the time of Jesus, is deeply documented in the historical record.
I am very much in favor of the State of Israel, but revisionist history is not the way to establish its legitimacy at all. We, just like I mentioned of Grok, should be maximally truth seeking too. I have no doubt that the situation there is compounded by the deliberate mixing of the population of imported Arabs, just as the British did with Protestants in Northern Ireland and the Ulster settlements, but the fact that the situation is complicated, even if maliciously so, does not change the reality of the situation on the ground, and the need for a fair settlement for all.
Fraser Orr: Sorry, more questions.
Who chose those core principles? Who can change them? I learned core principles and became somewhat conservative. Others learn core principles and became communists. Obviously, there are differing sets of core principles.
(Is this the alignment problem? Do I need to find a conservative-aligned A.I.? Are others going to seek a woke A.I.?)
@bobby b
Who chose those core principles? Who can change them?
The people who create and manage the AI. Here is an example about the big controversy over a new rule in claude about duplicating video games.
https://x.com/chasmmmmmmmmmmm/status/2116062991686721968
You will see in the image a file called claude.json. This is a set of rules that the Claude team controls and is baked into their AI and into their prompting filters. There are rules against things like generated naked pictures or stealing other people’s identity or building biological weapons and so on. Some of these are good rules, some are not.
These are more prompting rules, the rules are sort of included in the context of any prompts you type. But there are other sources of bias the occur during the training process. What is “training”? Basically AIs go through two phases: this first is training where an AI is fed a huge amount of data and other stuff, and then the training process compresses this down into a data structure called a neural network. This neural network contains a sort of summary of all the information it has consumed. And then this neural network is used in a process called inference that takes your prompt, runs it through the network and produces your result. This is what is called “generative AI”.
The AI does feast of a large amount of random data, but there is a lot more going on there too. There are at least two other processes that affect the training process: one is reinforcement learning, often called RL. This is a process where new data is created out of some sort of simulator and that data is fed into the AI training process too (for example for training an FSD network they will run a physics simulator representing a car driving and they will throw many exotic scenarios at it that they have not found in the real world data.) RL is also used as a sort of test suite to check that the neural net produced in training behaves in a way you expect it too. The second part is tagging, and in this process the network produces various results often several different options, and a human then rates the results to influence which is more likely.
So there are at least three ways the AI builders can influence the “core values” of an AI: via these prompt rules, through choice of RL data (and I suppose choice of real world data, but generally they just feed everything in raw) and through the choices the people in the tagging process make.
AIs like Gemini, the horrible ChatGPT, Claude (and probably Muse too, though I don’t know much about it) tend to be influenced by choices making them more woke in their responses. And the Chinese models of course are heavily influenced by the CCP and the rules they make. The philosophy underling grok is the prefer the objective over the subjective and that is how they chose RL data, how they write the prompt rules and how their taggers are trained. Most AI companies have a sort of constitution and a governance board that influences these things. I’m sure if you looked you could find what they say.
Of course the whole thing is much more complicated than that, but that is the 50,000 foot view.
So there is a lot going on and the philosophical underpinning of all these things influences the training process and consequently the neural network it produces. That network is then used in a process called inference to decide what the output is.
So there are a lot of parameters in the rules for prompting and the method of training that strongly influence the outcome. And this is where the difference lies. The Grok team has as its core principle that it seeks objective truth, and so it is trained with this approach. For example, a man cannot literally, objectively become a woman, but if you add politically correct rules to adjust that you can get a different outcome. Rules in a sense deliberately designed to bend from objectivity to preferred subjectivity.
I learned core principles and became somewhat conservative. Others learn core principles and became communists. Obviously, there are differing sets of core principles. (Is this the alignment problem? Do I need to find a conservative-aligned A.I.? Are others going to seek a woke A.I.?)
I wouldn’t think of it in this way. In fact it is something I have been thinking a lot about recently which is to say the lens in which we look at the world. Politicians are desperate for attention and are willing to sell influence to get it. And so they, and their friends in the media tend to try to make the populace see the world through a political lens. Everything, and I mean EVERYTHING is political and has a political solution. I am trying more and more to get away from this and try to view the world through a more objective lens of the things that are actually important, and, for sure, in my case, through a technology lens.
So to ask if an AI is political left or right seems to me to be the wrong way of looking at it. Let’s ask if it is focused on objective reality rather than an imagined political gestalt. Does what it says align with the real world or what the real world ought to be according to some political pundits. In fact it really comes back to that core idea that I think comes from Objectivism, but is probably earlier than Rand, namely the difference between ought and is.
So that is why I stick with Grok. Its core principles are about objective truth rather that political truth, it is about “is” not “ought to be”. To be clear, it’ll say things I don’t like or that I disagree with. But that’s ok. I disagree with many people here, but I still think their view is worth considering. And Grok has this wonderful feature that not only will it give you an answer but it’ll tell you why it thinks that, including extensive source material.
Well that is a very long answer to a very short question. In summary, chose Grok both because it gives you an objective view with biases minimized at its core principles and because we should support the people who are working to bring about the open, free society that we all desire.
It was the answer I was looking for. Thank you for the effort and detail!
Fraser – even in the 19th century most of the land was empty, indeed it was mostly either desert or maleria filled marshes. I have seen the graves of the people who turned the land into what it is now – they were not Muslims.
And in my own lifetime the population of such (then small) towns as Nazareth was mostly Christian. Although certainly there were Muslim villages – and many Muslims arrived (from Egypt and other places) at the end of the 19th century and in the early 20th century in order to take advantage of economic opportunities provided first by Jews and then by the British Mandate – the British enforced immigration controls on Jews (infamously leaving many Jews to be killed in Europe), but did NOT tend to enforce immigration controls on Muslims. A one sided immigration policy that caused much bitterness at the time – and still does, even though these days most Israeli Jews come from people who were driven out of Islamic countries NOT from European nations. Jews repeatedly tried to return to the land over the centuries – but tended to get slaughtered by Islamic forces, the community in Jerusalem clinging on by bribes – which the desperately poor people could ill afford.
Even Chairman Arafat was born and raised in Egypt – and he joined with Islamic fighters in the 1940s. The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem was NOT a Palestinian nationalist – the term “Palestinian”, back then, was mostly used by Jews to describe themselves. The Grand Mufti was fighting for Islam – that is why he made his alliance with Mr Hitler and Mr Himmler (although Mr Hitler was, basically, an atheist and Mr Himmler was a Pagan – and so both, technically, under Islamic law should have been executed).
“Palestinian Nationalism”, in the modern sense, was invented AFTER 1948 – largely by the KGB (as late as the 1960s).
Yes Islam has a claim to the land of Israel – but it is the same claim they have to the United States or anywhere else.
Islam teaches that the world was created by their God – Allah in Arabic (it is a great mistake to identify this being with the God of the Bible) and that, as the servants of Allah, the world belongs to them – although they will allow Christians and Jews to (possibly) live, as long as they pay the infidel tax in due humilation, and obey the various regulations that are designed to show their humiliation.
This would be true in Tel Aviv or on London or in New York – the geographical location is not relevant.
The idea that killing seven million Jews and giving Islam the land of Israel, would make the forces of Islam content is an error – they would not be content, not at all.
To them Michigan, or wherever, also rightly-belongs-to-them.
Wikipedia is leftist, like BBC, NYT, Reuters and other political media entities that designate Fidel Castro as a Cuban leader while Augusto Pinochet was a Chilean dictator
When we want find extremism you just have to go to those political media entities that legitimate dictators calling them leaders.
As of 20261101 these are the wikipedia entries first paragraphs.
Fidel Alejandro Castro Ruz[b] (13 August 1926 – 25 November 2016) was a Cuban revolutionary and politician who was the leader of Cuba from 1959 to 2011
Augusto José Ramón Pinochet Ugarte[a] (25 November 1915 – 10 December 2006) was a Chilean army officer and military dictator who ruled Chile from 1973 to 1990.
@Paul Marks
Fraser – even in the 19th century most of the land was empty, indeed it was mostly either desert or maleria filled marshes.
Here is what Grok says about it, citing 60 sources. Throughout history the population has varied enormously and for a lot of time it had a mainly Muslim or Arab population. To cite one statistic:
That isn’t densely population but it certainly isn’t “mostly empty”.
Again, I am very much pro a homeland for the Jews, but revisionist history is not the way to advocate for it.
BTW, the name “Jerusalem” ירושלים is Old Hebrew roughly translating to “Place of Peace” or “Foundation of Peace”, I’ve heard some say “Vision of Peace”. I vote for this being the most misnamed place in the history of the world.
I repeat the land was mostly empty.
Indeed much of it was either desert or malaria filled marsh. Vastly less developed, and less populated than it had been under Roman rule – the Romans and Byzantines were not kind to Jews (rather the opposite), but at least they maintained the land – which is more than the Islamic conquerers did.
Did you restore the land Fraser? No I do not think you did – and the Muslims did not either, I have seen the graves of the people who restored the land.
As for there being 300 thousand Muslims – even if that was true, there are vastly MORE Muslims there now, so what is your problem?
It was the Jews who were driven out of various lands in the Middle East – the Muslims have not been driven out of the Holy Land – there are more, vastly more, there now than there have ever been in history.
Indeed that is a terrible problem – as the election a few days ago showed. The “Economist” magazine with its demand that the “opposition parties in Israel work with the Arab parties” rather misses the point that the main policy of these Islamic (not “Arab”) parties is kill-the-Jews (and kill everyone else who does not submit).
No Islamic nation has to worry about how Jews vote – because they have driven them out or slit their throats, but Jews (and Christians) have to worry about the increasing voting strength of the followers of Islam.
Why do you think, for example, “France 24” is so rabid it its hatred of Jews? It follows this line to please the rising demographic in France itself.
As the demographic situation in Western nations (including the United States) gets worse – so the culture will change, became more Islamic.
Even Japan has agreed to import another 100 thousand fighting age Muslim men – that is NOT what the Japanese voters wanted when they voted in a “right wing” government.
The Japanese people, just like the French, the Germans and the British (and so on) have been betrayed.
It was not just Prime Minister Trudeau who uttered words of surrender “there is no such thing as Canadian culture”.
President Macron said “there is no such thing as French Culture – there are various cultures in France and ….”.
France needed a Charles Martel – and it got Emmanuel Macron.
The students may think they hate Macron – but really they are on the same side as him.
The side which is destroying the West.