We are developing the social individualist meta-context for the future. From the very serious to the extremely frivolous... lets see what is on the mind of the Samizdata people.

Samizdata, derived from Samizdat /n. - a system of clandestine publication of banned literature in the USSR [Russ.,= self-publishing house]

Samizdata quote of the day – Riotous Assemblies (a history of recent English aggro)

The subject of public disorder seems strangely topical, as I’m writing as rioting in France quietens down. Events in Paris and elsewhere have, inevitably, prompted a number of “what if?” comparisons with the UK. Our tradition of protest is significantly different from that of continental Europe, but that doesn’t mean we can afford to be complacent. On the other hand, nor is it necessarily a reason for panicky chief constables and sly mandarins to litigate for mega-forces, national police services and gendarmeries.

– Dominic Adler, discussing Blighty’s recent history of crowds kicking off. Part 1 is here, Part 2 is here.

7 comments to Samizdata quote of the day – Riotous Assemblies (a history of recent English aggro)

  • bobby b

    Perhaps I’m being cynical, but it strikes me that the best situation for Britain’s present Right would involve a lot of far-Left/Islamist rioting and burning.

  • Roué le Jour

    On the other hand, nor is it necessarily a reason for panicky chief constables and sly mandarins to litigate for mega-forces, national police services and gendarmeries.

    It’s a common conspiracy theory that the government is trying to provoke disorder in order to do exactly this.

    However, after considerable meditation on the structure of British government, the cabinet is now merely the bureaucracy’s PR department, and the bureaucracy itself is concerned only with the welfare of the bureaucracy, I believe the appropriate view is expressed by the maxim, “Never ascribe to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity.”

    We’re governed by idiots.

  • tim

    @Le Jour:

    I understand your point r.e. a conspiracy theory however I have direct experience of being on the end of police action at a mass protest which ensured that trouble ensued. I wouldn’t have believed it myself unless I had been there. It happens, it really does.

    And as for the main thrust of the article there are a few things to note:
    1) Times move on. We now have many radical leftists who are willing to riot and they weren’t around in the same numbers in the past.
    2) We have a growing number of malcontents who make up the benefits class who border on outright criminality and will jump at the chance to cause some mayhem.
    3) Not sure if Dominic has noticed but we have about a couple of million illegal immigrants living here combined with millions of new arrivals who don’t necessarily conform to the old ways of doing things.

  • Roué le Jour

    Tim,
    I witnessed police create an incident out of nothing as far back as the late eighties. It’s their normal behaviour I’m afraid, they don’t need any political encouragement.

    The normal sequence is that a police officer will behave with unnecessary aggression towards an innocent bystander. The bystander understandably objects to this and is now in conflict with an officer, and that’s a signal for every other copper in earshot to pile in. The initiating officer is quite often female, women in positions of authority generally behave worse than men in my experience.

  • tim

    @Le Jour
    Ok so you said it’s “a common conspiracy theory that the government is trying to provoke disorder in order to do exactly this.”
    And you then provide an example of a police officer doing just that.

    And I’m then telling you that in my experience at an extremely large protest, the police organised themselves, positioned themselves accordingly, and then acted collectively, as one, in a tactically designed manner which would guarantee confrontation and trouble.

    So then we agree with each other and it’s not a conspiracy?

  • Paul Marks

    2024 answered this question – there were relatively minor “right wing” disturbances, and the establishment released All-Hell upon them.

    The “right wingers” were denounced by the entire establishment (including by the King in his Christmas broadcast – which made it very clear which side the Gentleman was on) – and there were savage punishments for quite minor offenses (indeed sometimes for no real offense at all), with people told that if they did not plead guilty they would be punished even more savagely, all the “safeguards” in the “criminal justice system” were tossed out of the window (rapid trials – and conducted in a “Drum-Head” way) – as “right wingers” or people the state thinks are “right wingers” must be crushed by any means necessary.

    “Why do the British people not resist their destruction?” ask some people on this site. Because they are ruthlessly crushed when they engage in the slightest resistance – that is why.

    As for juries – somehow the left-establishment can rely upon them. Cross London to tell a angry mob to “cut the throats” of right-wingers – and a jury will find you “not guilty” – not guilty of any crime at all. But answer back journalists who have been harrassing you and your family – and a jury will find you “guilty” – when all you did is say that you will do to the journalists what they have done to you – you do NOT have to do anything, just SAYING you will doorstep journalists and ask them questions is enough for a jury to find you “guilty” – meanwhile the journalists who harrassed you and your family will not even be charged.

    I first noticed something rather odd about juries in this country when a jury found two traitors “not guilty” – traitors who openly admitted they “sprung” (helped escape to the Soviet Union) the traitor George Blake from prison. How many deaths was Mr Blake responsible for? It is contested – but he was certainly responsible for some deaths.

    There was no doubt as to the guilt of the traitors (may they burn in Hell) – they boasted of their crime in a book.

    The jury found them “not guilty” – because the jury were leftists, who should burn in Hell with the two defendants and Mr Blake. Yes the JURY should burn in Hell. Why not? They clearly approved of the conduct – they chose their side. The “jury system” only works if most people are not evil – if they are (which in this case they clearly were – like juries in so many large American cities, such as New York – but Washington D.C. as well, who will convict conservatives regardless-of-the-evidence, and will find leftists not-guilty reguardless-of-the-evidence) the system does NOT work. Not that the prosectution wanted the two found guilty, the prosecuting lawyer was clearly acting on instructions to throw-the-case, he enaged in no political argument at-all – when the case was clearly all about politics, about what side you are on. For or against the Soviet Union and the KGB.

    As for leftist riots – they are fine, the establishment love them. Indeed they use them as an excuse for even more corrupt DEI style policies and spending.

    The establishment are leftists – they may be leftists with cut-glass accents and expensive suits, but they are leftists.

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>