We are developing the social individualist meta-context for the future. From the very serious to the extremely frivolous... lets see what is on the mind of the Samizdata people.
Samizdata, derived from Samizdat /n. - a system of clandestine publication of banned literature in the USSR [Russ.,= self-publishing house]
|
Political earthquake in Poland I have been wading through various sources to try and make sense of the political confrontation in Poland. Any actual experts on Poland’s political scene care to weigh in? If so, keep it focused please, rather than hitting us with diatribes rather than analysis.
|
Who Are We? The Samizdata people are a bunch of sinister and heavily armed globalist illuminati who seek to infect the entire world with the values of personal liberty and several property. Amongst our many crimes is a sense of humour and the intermittent use of British spelling.
We are also a varied group made up of social individualists, classical liberals, whigs, libertarians, extropians, futurists, ‘Porcupines’, Karl Popper fetishists, recovering neo-conservatives, crazed Ayn Rand worshipers, over-caffeinated Virginia Postrel devotees, witty Frédéric Bastiat wannabes, cypherpunks, minarchists, kritarchists and wild-eyed anarcho-capitalists from Britain, North America, Australia and Europe.
|
Tousi TV and many others (including POLISH observers) are covering the conflict in Poland – which is part of wider European, indeed Global, conflict.
The Prime Minister of Poland, Mr Tusk, is entitled to appoint three members of the Polish Supreme Court (which he has already done) – but he wants to appoint more, in order to have a majority on the court.
Mr Tusk waited till the President of Poland (a conservative) was out of the country, and many Poles were at home to mark a religious holiday (conservative Polish people being more likely to return to family homes in rural areas for this event) – and then, with the backing of a minority of Supreme Court, sent in the police to enforce his changes to the Supreme Court (a constitutional coup), the President of Poland has returned to Poland and has announced that he is opposed to the coup.
As for “why” Mr Tusk is doing all this – it is the standard European Union and general International Community agenda – getting rid of what remains of Polish independence, getting rid of the national currency, open borders to mass migration from the Third World, abortion and the rest of the Social Revolution in order to further reduce the Polish fertility rate (the standard two prong attack to destroy an historic nation – undermine, further undermine, native fertility, plus mass migration of hostile populations and the natural increase, births, of these hostile populations).
None of the above is the personal idea of Mr Tusk – he is a loyal servant of the International Community and is carrying out its agenda.
One can expect similar conduct in the United States once the Democrats take Congress.
Which side the armed forces take will, in the end, be vital to deciding which side (globalist or nationalist) wins the conflict – whether in Poland, the United States, or elsewhere.
That’s a diatribe.
Unfortunatally most of the media in Poland follows the line of the International Community – the international Corporate State, that is true in most countries – including the United Kingdom and the United States, and the education system is (these days) much the same.
In this time of crises many conservative Polish people are likely to turn to the Roman Catholic Church – sadly they are likely to be betrayed, as Catholics in China (the underground Church that Cardinal McCarrick got the Vatican to betray) and Catholics in the United States (who go to church expecting Catholic religious instruction – and get leftist political messaging instead, and that messaging is ordered from the top of the earthly institution) were betrayed.
The long term infiltration of the Catholic Church (the human side of it – I am not making any theological point, and it is much the same in the Protestant churches) has had great success – it is, of course, part of the so called “long march through the institutions” which has seen the left take over just about every institution in so many nations.
The Chicago area is especially hard hit – going back to the days of Cardinal Berardin – he of the “seamless garment” theology, the position that someone could not be a Catholic without supporting all new doctrines imposed by the people who had taken positions of power in the institution, and then quietly downplaying the traditional doctrines.
Such people as the late Cardinals McCarrick (not Chicago – he came from the New York area) and Berardin were highly intelligent and hard working men – who, it must be admitted, made great sacrifices, spending many years (indeed many decades) dressing up and going through the motions of a religion they despised. Cardinal Cupich is also a hard working, learned, and highly intelligent man – working for what he truly believes will be a better world, reinterpreting the concept of “Heaven” to mean this world, and, like many of his colleagues who have infiltrated Protestant churches, holding that “salvation” is not survival of the individual after death – but is Collective Salvation.
It must be a great trial for him to have to deal with people so much less intelligent than himself – and to have to pretend to share what he considers to be their primitive and superstitious beliefs.
One does not to share their political agenda (and I certainly do not share it) to have some sympathy for people, whatever country they are in, who have to, for decades, “live a lie” – it must be a terrible strain.
Still let us hope that people in Poland will NOT be betrayed – although, given who is now Pope (a Gentleman who has praised the late Cardinal Bernadin and the very much alive Cardinal Cupich – and has himself been involved in certian political activities since at least 1983), it seems unfortunately likely that they will be – but we shall have to see.
Who knows – perhaps things will turn out well.
Clearly I was wasting pixels writing that 😑
OK, back of an envelope so far …
Poland has a constitutional court to keep a check on politicians. It was changed by a nationalist government in 2015 and Poland is in dispute with the ECJ over legality.
Court president is Bogdan Święczkowski (Nationalist, goodie.)
Poland prime minister Donald Tusk (EU stooge, baddie) wants to pack the court with his allies. He is allowed to appoint 3 judges, wants more. He waited until the Polish president, Karol Nawrocki (Nationalist, goodie) was off on a jolly. Tusk stooge Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska (Baddie) took over the court and suspended the president and his deputy. The court building was then locked and surrounded by riot police This kept out the court president and co. plus a gathering protest of Polish people, who know only too well what an incipient dictatorship leads to.
Polish president, Karol Nawrocki, turned his plane around in mid-air and returned to Warsaw. There are reports that his plane was refused landing permission but the military pilot landed anyway, that he had to force his way to the courthouse and cut open the gates with a power saw. He then went in with court Vice-President, Judge Bartłomiej Sochański (also goodie) and declared the takeover unconstitutional.
Personal take: Tusk has shot his bolt and will go the way of all failed EU functionaries, into a nice little sinecure in the Brussels swamp.
I found that the Polish President being en route to Senegal at the time Tusk launched his ‘coup’ curious.
In the past it has been common for African leaders to be abroad when coups against them take place (King Idris, Obote, Nkrumah etc)…
Also curious that the proposed solutions to ‘democratic backsliding’ is stuff that looks awfully like ‘democratic backsliding’. I won’t diatribe though as I have no emotional investment in domestic Polish politics
Indeed, it stinks like two week old fish.
“If so, keep it focused please, rather than hitting us with diatribes rather than analysis.”
Clearly I was wasting pixels writing that.
No shit.
Steven Barrett Barrister has a half an hour long examiniation of this matter on YouTube.
He comes to the same conclusions as I do (the Gentleman just takes longer to do so) – I do not see why a shorter version (a few pargraphs) should be discribed as a “diatribe”.
The European Union (and the International Community generally) wants new judges on the Polish Supreme Court in order to negate the Constitution of Poland and impose the policies of the International Community (on everything from abortion, to free migration, to the currency). So it wants Supreme Court judges appointed in such a way that will make sure that they follow the line of the international establishment – and, in effect, use the Constitution of Poland for toilet paper, just as Progressive judges do with the United States Constitution and State Constitutions.
Mr Tusk, as a faithful follower of the International Community, has sent in the police to enforce this.
I am not sorry if people regard writing the basic facts as somehow shocking – as these are the basic facts.
What may matter most is what side the Polish armed forces take – the side of the President or the Prime Minister – the Nationalists or the Internationalists.
The same is true in the United States – or rather will be true (in some form or another) next year.
Perry and IrishOtter49 should stop acting like maiden aunts having an attack of the vapours.
It is not my fault that the world is not the nice place you want it to be.
As for the Cardinals – I was careful NOT to be shocking, only mentioning their political activities (every other Sunday service in the United States is now a Free Migration political “diatribe” – with the agenda of getting people to vote Democrat in spite of, or rather BECAUSE of, the hatred, utter hatred, the Democratic Party, which reflects the universities, has for traditional Christian teaching – on the family and everything else).
I did not even mention their sexual activities – the abuse of boys and so on, for which the Soviet and PRC Agent of Influence Cardinal McCarrick (and so many others) are well known.
I stand amazed at my own moderation.
Yes the whole thing “stinks like two week old fish” – and it is not a “diatribe” for Martin or Perry (or me) to point that out.
But Mr Donald Tusk, Prime Minister of Poland, is not some madman who decided to lauch a coup because he got out of bed the wrong side one morning – he is a faithful follower of the European Union and the International Community.
This is part of a global conflict of Nationalists vs Internationalists, or “Globalists” (which very much includes the conflict in the United Kingdom and the United States) – it is NOT about one bad-man.
He does not act alone or without instruction and support.
And it is much the same with the “rebel students” – in Serbia (who now have a majority in Parliament – promising more government spending on everything – and whose “freedom” turns out to mean MORE “Hate Speech” regulations, and MORE power for the Serbian version of the “Press Council”) France, Belgium, Germany and so on.
They may sincerely believe they are “rebels” – but they pushing the agenda of the international establishment.
The rule of officials and “experts” (including “expert judges” who can relied upon to give “Progressive” judgements) which, they have been taught, will bring happinesss.
“You will own nothing – and you will be happy” – whether it is a philosopher such as the late Bertrand Russell, or some student on the street smashing windows, the agenda is the same.
The people of the World Economic Forum, the United Nations, and the rest of the international establishment are, no doubt, rather pleased.
Then tell us which parts of what PM said are wrong.
I ask because his facts match well with most of what I’ve seen so far.
bobby b
PM was lazy – he just typed out the conclusions of various lawyers (British and Polish) who have studied the matter, not the page-after-page of detailed argument.
But they I have been told my comments are too long.
In the end this will not be settled by words – it will be settled by which side the armed forces back.
My fear is that with their “training” the officiers will obey Mr Tusk (and his Defense Minister) as faithful servants of the International Community.
Why do you think Pete Hegseth is working so hard to weed out officers in the American military whose loyalty is to the international community and the Progressive cause – but he is not doing enough.
I am on the side of Perry and IrishOtter on this issue:
What we need right now is a factual analysis of the kind that Druid 144 provided. (With brief value judgements between brackets.)
But then, i do not mind Paul’s speculations; if for no other reason, because i do not have to read them …
Incidentally, Tusk’s attempted coup is being compared to a color recolution; but that strikes me as misguided, since most if not all “color revolutions” seem to me to have had popular support.
Personally I have no horse in the race (tho I may have preferences) but I would like it to be noted who in the UK is in favour of what Tusk is doing, so if a Reform Government (one can dream) did the same to our Supreme Court their previous statements supporting politicians removing judges can be replayed to them.
One way to help matters along might be for President Trump to say that if this coup continues, and Mr Tusk and cronies remain in office, he will exercise America’s ‘Polish Veto’ on action under Article 5 were Poland to be attacked, i.e. saying ‘You’re not worth defending now, so you are on your own as far as the United States is concerned.’
Then the Poles would have a terrible choice.
Is the following correct?
This statement seems rather at odds with the images from Paris and Berlin recently of hordes of feral youths raiding Johnny Foreigner’s version of Foot Locker. If anything, they seemed over the moon with their newly aquired possessions.
“If there is hope, it lies in the proles” as a wiser man than I once wrote.
Here is another account. I cannot assess the claims, but it provides some more context.
Landeur on Youtube gives a good explanation of the Polish Constitution and how it evolved to essentially keep Poland Polish.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8YpLvv_CtgQ
The court that Tusk is appointing the judges to is there to examine proposed legislation to ensure that it is not in conflict with the written Constitution.
Tusk seems to want to legislate from the courtroom and by appointing compliant judges who will say that black is white, then the Constitution can be at best ignored, likely abolished.
The President must swear in the judges and he has refused to do so … for obvious reasons.
You are ranting about the catholic church in the United States after I asked for explanations about current events in Poland, Paul, POLAND.
In response to bobby:
I have nothing against Paul M providing his own interpretations of current events: I just wish that he made a clear distinction between “facts” and his interpretations unsupported by facts.
EG Paul claims that the Tusk coup aims at implementing an “international community” (“globalist”) agenda, which includes the destruction of national independence, open borders, and the destruction of the traditional family.
That might well be true in the specific case of Poland, but where is the evidence?
Just a few weeks ago, Tusk was blaming the French riots on immigration, FFS!
@Snorri
Why would Paul M state that Tusk wants to implement a globalist agenda? Umm let’s see:
a) was previously the Head of the European Council
b) led the European People’s Party after this
c) favours European integration
d) backed the Lisbon treaty.
I don’t know. It sounds like mindless silly speculation doesn’t it.
Or……
Mr Ed – it is difficult. Yes it makes logical sense to say “we will not defend this government in Poland – it is a corrupt servant of the International Community, the same Internatonal Community that also wishes to crush the independence of the United States, crush the liberty of the American people” – but then there are the PEOPLE of Poland to consider, would it be just to just leave them undefended if, for example, Mr Putin tried nuclear blackmail?
tim – yes, there was nothing contraversial in what I typed about the situation in Poland. It has all been known for some time. What I wrote about the leftist infiltration of the churches in the United States (and elsewhere) is hardly a new discovery either – it has been known for years, indeed I might justly be accused of being boring – of telling people what they already know.
It is very strange that Perry, Irish Otter, and others, reacted in the way they did.
As for the Lisbon Treaty – its core is that the European Union is supreme in anything it says it is supreme in. That is unlimited power.
Although one must remember that the European Union is only part of the international agenda – the final aim is global governance by a series of treaties and agreements.
It is true that not everyone would “own nothing and be happy” (be happy – or else be punished).
A small Corporate elite would continue to own property – or, at least, so they fondly believe.
They want socialism for everyone else – and capitalism for themselves.
I suspect that things would not turn out quite the way they want – they want Henri Saint-Simon style Collectivism, but they are more likely to get a savage mob that will find some way into their private estates.
Tim: you are failing to heed the 1st rule of prognostication:
Never make predictions, especially about the future.
You are also failing to appreciate that i have nothing against Paul repeating what he has been saying for decades.
All what i wish is that he drew a line between the latter, and remarks specific to the current Polish crisis.
@Snorri
If you don’t use available evidence to reach a conclusion then it’s not clever. It sounds like you’re just here to cause an argument.
The American Conference of Bishops have now demanded that non citizens be included in the 2030 census – including what they call law abiding non documented immigrants (that someone who entered the country illegally is not “law abiding” – somehow escapes them, ditto all robbery, rape and murder committed by the “law abiding”) – this is a political demand, all about giving the Dems more seats in the House of Representatives.
But the sickening thing is that it is not presented as a political demand – it is a presented in RELIGIOUS (pretend religious) langaguge, couched in the theology of personhood, and the supposedly limitless dignity of personhood.
Only someone who not only lacked religious faith, but had an active hatred (yes – hatred) for religious faith, would use such religious language for a demand which is about getting the Dems (or the Republicans) more House seats. It is squalid – an utterlly squalid thing to do, and it is very revealing of the character of the men who have done it (squalid – but sadly effective with people who mistakenly think these men have deep religious faith).
Bishop Strickland (Biship of Tyler Texas – before he was removed, really for the crime of actually believing in Catholic doctrines) is no friend of Jews (in the same way that Sir “Genocide” Davey is no friend) – but at least he believes in his own religion.
At meetings with his fellow Bishops he used to ask why they were not campaigning, as Catholic doctrine says they should, against the homosexual agenda, and against baby killing – he might as well have been asking acid why it was not alkaline – many of the men he was talking to, think that traditional Christianity is a load of silly nonsense, spreading it is the last thing they would want to do. Some of them used to look at Bishop Stickland with amused contempt (“how did someone who actually BELIEVES in Christianity, become a Bishop?”).
Many of them are not opposed to corrupting boys (they are interested in this subject – but rather from the other side), and they are far more likely to give awards to people who fund mass baby killing (which Cardinal Cupich of Chicago, the mentor of Robert Provost, has just done), that to oppose these people.
I express no theological opinions (none) myself on all this – but it is interesting to see how much people people who despise Christianity, as it was traditionally understood (before such words as “God” and “Heaven” were redefined to mean Earthly things), now have in the Christian Churches. Most certainly NOT just in the Catholic Church – in all the “mainline” churches.
And given who is now Pope (and who the last Pope was) – I very much doubt if Poland is immune from this.
Those Polish people who appeal to the church in Poland saying that “Brussels will lead us to more feminism, and to mass abortion and the Trans agenda and…..” may receive support – but I suspect they will not recieve much support (it will be window dressing – paying lip service to traditional doctrines).
Friday, 30 October: Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska announced the suspension of Constitutional Tribunal President Bogdan Święczkowski and Vice-President Bartłomiej Sochański. She asserted authority to lead the court.
However, while Judge Anna was picked to be a Judge by the Parliament (i.e. Tusk), the Polish Constitution requires her to be sworn in by the President. The President has declined to hear her oath of office.
Now Tusk’s supporters say that the President has no right to decline to hear the oath. As a technical matter, if correct that might put him in the wrong without necessarily meaning that she has the legal authority of a judge. If her oath before the President is a requirement for assuming office and she hasn’t taken it, that’s that for her authority.
But there’s two sides to the story of the President’s behaviour.
Tusk’s people say the constitutional obligation to take the oath cannot be used toto frustrate Parliament’s lawful appointment of a new judge. The President’s role is merely ceremonial, and in these circumstances unnecessary. So she was “sworn in” by the Speaker of the Parliament. If that counts.
The President’s side says swearing in before the President is not optional. So refusing to hear the oath counts as a veto. According to them, while the Parliament has the right of appointment, the President has the right of consent.
Now naively I would think that deciding between these two readings of the Polish constitution is the job of the Polish Constitutional Court, but hey, what do I know? Tusk appears to think he can decide it himself.
It’s also complicated by the fact that there have been two rulings by the Constitutional Court on closely related questions, closely enough that people are saying the matter is decided. One in 2015, and one in 2024. The one in 2015 is helpful to Tusk’s argument; the one in 2024 is helpful to the President.
Another couple of examples of shenanigans:
1. Tusk waited until the President was on a flight to Senegal. When the President turned his plane around to support the existing Constitutional Court, Tusk gave orders to deny the President permission to land in Warsaw. These orders were ignored.
2. Tusk’s side is making a great deal of the claim that the President cannot frustrate the lawful decision of Parliament by refusing to carry out a task appointed to him by the Constitution. But Tusk’s government is doing something very similar, with far less of a defensible excuse. Remember that 2024 Constitutional Court ruling I mentioned that was helpful to the President? Well technically court rulings only come into effect when published in the official Gazette. And for the past two years, Tusk’s government has been refusing to publish the rulings of the Constitutional Court in the official Gazette…
A couple of other items worth thinking about:
1. About a month ago, Tusk met with Alissa “deep state” Slotkin.
2. More recently, Tusk met with Obama.
Positive evidence of anything? No.
Nothing more than a coincidence? I think not, especially in the broader context; but you are welcome to your own conclusions.