We are developing the social individualist meta-context for the future. From the very serious to the extremely frivolous... lets see what is on the mind of the Samizdata people.
Samizdata, derived from Samizdat /n. - a system of clandestine publication of banned literature in the USSR [Russ.,= self-publishing house]
One thing that both sides agree on is that if the new judges go on the court the Supreme Court in Poland will give “Progressive” judgements.
So the issue really is – is the Constitution of Poland as-written to be followed, or a Progressive “Living Constitution” to be followed – “Living Constitution” that will be in accord with the policies of the European Union and the International Community.
This is not about Poland alone, or about one person, Mr Tusk, just happening to be a bad man (from his own point of view, and the point of view of the International Community he is NOT a bad man – to them it is his Nationalist opponents who are bad people) – this is a global conflict between Nationalists and Internationalists – it is the same in the United Kingdom and the United States.
And in every case – what will matter, in the end, is which side the armed forces back.
In Poland the Prime Minister, Mr Tusk, has been allowed a television address to get people on his side – but, as far as I know, the elected President has not had a television address.
Next year (2027) there is likely to be a similar conflict in the United States – between the President and the newly Democrat Party controlled (International Community supporting) Congress. However, given the RINOs (such as John Roberts – the Chief Justice) on the United States Supreme Court the conflict is likely to be a quick and decisive victory for the International Community – the international establishment, Corporate State (which most officials and so on in the United States already serve).
The independence of the United States and what remains of the liberty of the American people will, de facto, be ended.
Paul: it means letting one’s emotions such as anger – no matter how justified – get the better of him.
Bobby: the guy seems to be ‘old Left‘, but I’m sure Brits here know far more than I do. Also and FWIW, what he says partly chimes with what a friend who lives in Poland told me a couple of years ago. It doesn’t contradict what Paul is saying either, BTW.
Alisa – Craig Murray said what I said, that the European Union wants a court that will rule their way and that Mr Tusk is trying to deliver that.
He just used more words to say it – and also (unfortunatly) put in things which are not true, for example that Mr Tusk and his associates are themselves are on the right, which they are not. I have even heard socialists claim that Prime Minister Blair was a “right winger” – which he be from their perspective, but not from mine. Would a right winger support the Lisbon Treaty under which the European Union has supreme power in anything it declares it has supreme power in (total – unlimited, power). Mr Tusk supports the Lisbon Treaty.
I have not let my emotions get the better of me – I have just stated the facts, horrible as they are.
Paul, the reason his article is far more useful than your comments is that most of it is his explaining things about Poland that I didn’t know, while your comments keep repeating the same general points over and over again (notwithstanding those points being as correct as they generally are).
As to anger, you were the one who brought it up. If you did not type all those comments out of anger, then my comment about hand-waving doesn’t apply to you anyway (and it wasn’t meant to, BTW). If you are interested who I was thinking of, let me know.
No, Paul, Craig isn’t perfect by any means. I mean he’s an ex-diplomat, a scottish nationalist, and a LibDem, for goodness sake, but he does appear to know more than a fair bit about the constitutional game of musical chairs currently underway in Poland.
I don’t think either that the left/right labelling applies. The point is that Poland is in many ways very culturally conservative, has historically been intensely Catholic. I have been to Poland BTW, a few years ago. it was fantastic- prosperous, hard-working, friendly, clean. Like an English market town in 1970 but with computers and mobile phones.
Tusk and his cronies are not left or right. They’re creatures now of the establishment elite of Europe. Pan-european parasites and I-know-besters of the most repellant kind.
Alisa – I repeat the same points (about many subjects) again and again – because people keep denying them.
mongoose – “he’s an ex-dioplomat, a Scottish nationalist, and a LibDem” – well that is three strikes against him. But YES it is good that even such a person admits part (part) of the truth.
As for Scottish “Nationalism” it is (like the Welsh version) entirely fake – someone who wants every policy decided by international authorities is not a Nationalist – they are opposite of a Nationalist.
I agree with you that Mr Tusk and co are part of the international establishment – both pro European Union and pro global (world) governance.
Such people are everywhere.
They are about to take over the United States Congress.
“You will own nothing” takes another step on the road to Agenda 2030.
Besides, the more i think about this, the more i believe that Tusk and other people involved in this attempted coup should suffer the full force of the law, irrespective of whether the coup was pro-EU or anti-EU.
Alisa – I have. At least that is how I interpret abusive replies (from IrishOtter or whoever) – I interpret them to mean disagreement – just disagreement that is too lazy to point out where I am supposed to be wrong.
Snorri Godhi – Mr Tusk, on behalf of his international community masters, is trying to take over “the law”.
This is the point I have made several times, which Alisa thinks I do not need to make – but clearly I do.
“The force of law” will be the International Community – of which the European Union is a part (but only a part).
It will not be any different in the United States – the Democrats have made it very clear (as part of the International Establishment) that they intend to subject people who support the Nationalist Trump Administration – to the “full force of the law”.
The “full force of the law” – their law, their courts, their punishments.
I remind you – a big city jury would find any supporter of President Trump guilty of burning Rome in 64 AD.
No evidence or argument would be required – they would be guilty by virtue of the fact that they are on the other side politically.
That is also what Prime Minister Tusk means by the “full force of the law”.
And he is just a representative – a representive of the international establishment, he is not some rogue bad man who came up with this himself.
Again this is a point I have already made – several times. But it is clear that I have to make the point again.
This is the point I have made several times, which Alisa thinks I do not need to make – but clearly I do.
You still haven’t told us who contests your point, Paul!
Perhaps you can relax if you accept that nobody HERE contests it.
Except maybe in the details.
Paul: i do not think that you do justice to IrishOtter.
All what he wrote is that your previous comment was a diatribe.
Later, he wrote “no shit!” when Perry concurred.
Whether your comment was a diatribe or not, says nothing about whether IrishOtter agrees with the substance of it.
If i may take myself as an example:
I agree with IrishOtter and Perry about the diatribish nature of some of your comments, entirely or in parts. At the same time, i do not disagree with your contention that there is a conspiracy by the EU deep.state — although claiming that Tusk is nothing more than a puppet of the deep.state, is going a bit too far.
Isn’t this evidence that calling your comment a diatribe does not imply disagreement?
Paul, people who use abusive language and personal attacks often do so because they have their own issues or agendas. They may agree or disagree on substance, or may not even care at all (trolls). Repeating the same points over and over has no effect on such people, but it can and does put off honest and curious readers. I suggest it’s best to avoid feeding trolls, and focus on informing honest readers and commenters instead.
So, since nothing really became clear back when this post was made, here’s some new material (although it’s probably invisible and buried by now):
“Imagine if Joe Biden had Clarence Thomas removed from the Supreme Court because he was “jeopardizing the Supreme Court’s work,” sent capitol police to surround the Supreme Court building and tried to swear in three new Supreme Court justices the Senate had rejected, and that’s essentially what went down.”
It is not my place to agree or disagree, since the whole point of the post itself – as I see it – is to gather information that’s not obvious to outside observers such as myself. So far, the only post that provided any such information has been Craig Murray’s article linked here earlier.
Imagine if Joe Biden had Clarence Thomas removed from the Supreme Court because he was “jeopardizing the Supreme Court’s work,” sent capitol police to surround the Supreme Court building and tried to swear in three new Supreme Court justices the Senate had rejected, and that’s essentially what went down.
This is exactly the kind of “argument” I find most unhelpful when it comes from outside observers, and what I referred to earlier as hand-waving. I see this time and again done by American conservatives who are friendly to Israel with regard to the latter, by Israeli conservatives who are friendly to America with regard to America, and by everyone else who project their own experiences and desires to countries they know very little about.
Again, just to clarify: this not an a agreement or disagreement on my part, just skepticism as someone who knows very little about Poland. YMMV.
To be fair and in an effort to point to information rather than mere opinion, this link from the one posted by Bobby seems more informative than others. The writer is an Hungarian conservative, but his own linking to Polish sources at least suggests that he may be understanding the language.
bobby b – well yes, this is what happened. Anyone who defends puppets of the International Community, such as Prime Minister Tusk, is clearly a scumbag – I do not believe anyone here will seriously deny the basic facts. I will not repeat them again in this comment – we all know the basic facts by now.
The latest twist is that a “far rightist” has murdered several people – which will give the establishment an excuse for a crackdown.
“So far, the only post that provided any such information has been Craig Murray’s article linked here earlier.”
Yeah, that was kind of my point in making that comment. At least where I am, the entire story has just disappeared. I come back here, and see one comment giving information. Given the (I assume) importance of the situation, it’s rather frustratingly occulted.
So I threw out this para by LP – one of the few attempts I’ve seen anywhere to summarize what happened – in an attempt to get SOME factual info, if only in reaction to perceived inaccuracy.
So, let’s not talk about this and maybe it will go away? That’s usually some part of the explanation when something just drops out of sight without info.
Bobby: I think there are two main explanations for this, at least for now. The first and most obvious one is the language barrier. Again, I base this on my experience with reporting on Israel: someone one who doesn’t understand Hebrew will have a hard time following what’s really going on here. And I assume that from an average American’s POV Poland is even more obscure (fewer individuals who maintain close ties to both countries, plus the no-Jews-no-news maxim).
The other reason may be that the situation in Poland is still unfolding – i.e. there are literally no news, at least not yet. In Israel it’s the other way around: too much news, all the time – blink and you miss it. But that’s a whole different subject. I may well be wrong about this re Poland and things may be moving fast over there as well – but I have no way of knowing, because of language.
BTW, I forgot all about Visegrad24. I believe that Stefan Tompson has a Polish background. Problem is, they try to cover everything (although mostly Europe, UK and the ME). Currently and as pertinent to Poland, it’s all about that “right-wing” shooter in Krakow…
The Samizdata people are a bunch of sinister and heavily armed globalist illuminati who seek to infect the entire world with the values of personal liberty and several property. Amongst our many crimes is a sense of humour and the intermittent use of British spelling.
We are also a varied group made up of social individualists, classical liberals, whigs, libertarians, extropians, futurists, ‘Porcupines’, Karl Popper fetishists, recovering neo-conservatives, crazed Ayn Rand worshipers, over-caffeinated Virginia Postrel devotees, witty Frédéric Bastiat wannabes, cypherpunks, minarchists, kritarchists and wild-eyed anarcho-capitalists from Britain, North America, Australia and Europe.
All content on this website (including text, photographs, audio files, and any other original works), unless otherwise noted, is licensed under a Creative Commons License. Powered by WordPress & Atahualpa
One thing that both sides agree on is that if the new judges go on the court the Supreme Court in Poland will give “Progressive” judgements.
So the issue really is – is the Constitution of Poland as-written to be followed, or a Progressive “Living Constitution” to be followed – “Living Constitution” that will be in accord with the policies of the European Union and the International Community.
This is not about Poland alone, or about one person, Mr Tusk, just happening to be a bad man (from his own point of view, and the point of view of the International Community he is NOT a bad man – to them it is his Nationalist opponents who are bad people) – this is a global conflict between Nationalists and Internationalists – it is the same in the United Kingdom and the United States.
And in every case – what will matter, in the end, is which side the armed forces back.
In Poland the Prime Minister, Mr Tusk, has been allowed a television address to get people on his side – but, as far as I know, the elected President has not had a television address.
Next year (2027) there is likely to be a similar conflict in the United States – between the President and the newly Democrat Party controlled (International Community supporting) Congress. However, given the RINOs (such as John Roberts – the Chief Justice) on the United States Supreme Court the conflict is likely to be a quick and decisive victory for the International Community – the international establishment, Corporate State (which most officials and so on in the United States already serve).
The independence of the United States and what remains of the liberty of the American people will, de facto, be ended.
Craig Murray seems to have some insight. Here.
Thanks so much mongoose. Finally an informed and calm analysis rather than furious hand-waving.
@mongoose
Thanks for that, great article have sent that on elsewhere.
So much depends upon writers.
What do we think about the veracity and the insight of Craig Murray? Does he hand-wave, or analyze?
As Aristotle pointed out – it is correct to be angry in the face of evil.
What is being done in Poland, and many other nations, is evil – so it is correct be angry about it.
I have no idea what “hand waving” is supposed to mean.
Paul: it means letting one’s emotions such as anger – no matter how justified – get the better of him.
Bobby: the guy seems to be ‘old Left‘, but I’m sure Brits here know far more than I do. Also and FWIW, what he says partly chimes with what a friend who lives in Poland told me a couple of years ago. It doesn’t contradict what Paul is saying either, BTW.
Alisa – Craig Murray said what I said, that the European Union wants a court that will rule their way and that Mr Tusk is trying to deliver that.
He just used more words to say it – and also (unfortunatly) put in things which are not true, for example that Mr Tusk and his associates are themselves are on the right, which they are not. I have even heard socialists claim that Prime Minister Blair was a “right winger” – which he be from their perspective, but not from mine. Would a right winger support the Lisbon Treaty under which the European Union has supreme power in anything it declares it has supreme power in (total – unlimited, power). Mr Tusk supports the Lisbon Treaty.
I have not let my emotions get the better of me – I have just stated the facts, horrible as they are.
Paul, the reason his article is far more useful than your comments is that most of it is his explaining things about Poland that I didn’t know, while your comments keep repeating the same general points over and over again (notwithstanding those points being as correct as they generally are).
As to anger, you were the one who brought it up. If you did not type all those comments out of anger, then my comment about hand-waving doesn’t apply to you anyway (and it wasn’t meant to, BTW). If you are interested who I was thinking of, let me know.
No, Paul, Craig isn’t perfect by any means. I mean he’s an ex-diplomat, a scottish nationalist, and a LibDem, for goodness sake, but he does appear to know more than a fair bit about the constitutional game of musical chairs currently underway in Poland.
I don’t think either that the left/right labelling applies. The point is that Poland is in many ways very culturally conservative, has historically been intensely Catholic. I have been to Poland BTW, a few years ago. it was fantastic- prosperous, hard-working, friendly, clean. Like an English market town in 1970 but with computers and mobile phones.
Tusk and his cronies are not left or right. They’re creatures now of the establishment elite of Europe. Pan-european parasites and I-know-besters of the most repellant kind.
Alisa – I repeat the same points (about many subjects) again and again – because people keep denying them.
mongoose – “he’s an ex-dioplomat, a Scottish nationalist, and a LibDem” – well that is three strikes against him. But YES it is good that even such a person admits part (part) of the truth.
As for Scottish “Nationalism” it is (like the Welsh version) entirely fake – someone who wants every policy decided by international authorities is not a Nationalist – they are opposite of a Nationalist.
I agree with you that Mr Tusk and co are part of the international establishment – both pro European Union and pro global (world) governance.
Such people are everywhere.
They are about to take over the United States Congress.
“You will own nothing” takes another step on the road to Agenda 2030.
Bookmarking this for later.
I repeat – someone who wants policy decided by international authorities is not a patriot.
They are, by definition, an anti-patriot.
A patriot is someone who supports the independence of their nation.
Paul, I have never seen any of these points being denied here.
What Alisa said @2:50pm.
Besides, the more i think about this, the more i believe that Tusk and other people involved in this attempted coup should suffer the full force of the law, irrespective of whether the coup was pro-EU or anti-EU.
Alisa – I have. At least that is how I interpret abusive replies (from IrishOtter or whoever) – I interpret them to mean disagreement – just disagreement that is too lazy to point out where I am supposed to be wrong.
Snorri Godhi – Mr Tusk, on behalf of his international community masters, is trying to take over “the law”.
This is the point I have made several times, which Alisa thinks I do not need to make – but clearly I do.
“The force of law” will be the International Community – of which the European Union is a part (but only a part).
It will not be any different in the United States – the Democrats have made it very clear (as part of the International Establishment) that they intend to subject people who support the Nationalist Trump Administration – to the “full force of the law”.
The “full force of the law” – their law, their courts, their punishments.
I remind you – a big city jury would find any supporter of President Trump guilty of burning Rome in 64 AD.
No evidence or argument would be required – they would be guilty by virtue of the fact that they are on the other side politically.
That is also what Prime Minister Tusk means by the “full force of the law”.
And he is just a representative – a representive of the international establishment, he is not some rogue bad man who came up with this himself.
Again this is a point I have already made – several times. But it is clear that I have to make the point again.
Paul: so you are going to repeat the same thing over and over and over again, until IrishOtter or whoever agree with you?
You still haven’t told us who contests your point, Paul!
Perhaps you can relax if you accept that nobody HERE contests it.
Except maybe in the details.
Snorri Godhi.
As I said – I interpret abusive replies as disagreement.
Someone like “IrishOtter” does not write “I disagree with you – for the following reasons….”
But it is clear from their hostility that they disagree.
Paul: i do not think that you do justice to IrishOtter.
All what he wrote is that your previous comment was a diatribe.
Later, he wrote “no shit!” when Perry concurred.
Whether your comment was a diatribe or not, says nothing about whether IrishOtter agrees with the substance of it.
If i may take myself as an example:
I agree with IrishOtter and Perry about the diatribish nature of some of your comments, entirely or in parts. At the same time, i do not disagree with your contention that there is a conspiracy by the EU deep.state — although claiming that Tusk is nothing more than a puppet of the deep.state, is going a bit too far.
Isn’t this evidence that calling your comment a diatribe does not imply disagreement?
Paul, people who use abusive language and personal attacks often do so because they have their own issues or agendas. They may agree or disagree on substance, or may not even care at all (trolls). Repeating the same points over and over has no effect on such people, but it can and does put off honest and curious readers. I suggest it’s best to avoid feeding trolls, and focus on informing honest readers and commenters instead.
So, since nothing really became clear back when this post was made, here’s some new material (although it’s probably invisible and buried by now):
https://www.battleswarmblog.com/?p=73993
Anyone disagree with this analysis?
It is not my place to agree or disagree, since the whole point of the post itself – as I see it – is to gather information that’s not obvious to outside observers such as myself. So far, the only post that provided any such information has been Craig Murray’s article linked here earlier.
This is exactly the kind of “argument” I find most unhelpful when it comes from outside observers, and what I referred to earlier as hand-waving. I see this time and again done by American conservatives who are friendly to Israel with regard to the latter, by Israeli conservatives who are friendly to America with regard to America, and by everyone else who project their own experiences and desires to countries they know very little about.
Again, just to clarify: this not an a agreement or disagreement on my part, just skepticism as someone who knows very little about Poland. YMMV.
To be fair and in an effort to point to information rather than mere opinion, this link from the one posted by Bobby seems more informative than others. The writer is an Hungarian conservative, but his own linking to Polish sources at least suggests that he may be understanding the language.
Alisa you may indeed have a point about trolls.
bobby b – well yes, this is what happened. Anyone who defends puppets of the International Community, such as Prime Minister Tusk, is clearly a scumbag – I do not believe anyone here will seriously deny the basic facts. I will not repeat them again in this comment – we all know the basic facts by now.
The latest twist is that a “far rightist” has murdered several people – which will give the establishment an excuse for a crackdown.
Yeah, that was kind of my point in making that comment. At least where I am, the entire story has just disappeared. I come back here, and see one comment giving information. Given the (I assume) importance of the situation, it’s rather frustratingly occulted.
So I threw out this para by LP – one of the few attempts I’ve seen anywhere to summarize what happened – in an attempt to get SOME factual info, if only in reaction to perceived inaccuracy.
So, let’s not talk about this and maybe it will go away? That’s usually some part of the explanation when something just drops out of sight without info.
Bobby: I think there are two main explanations for this, at least for now. The first and most obvious one is the language barrier. Again, I base this on my experience with reporting on Israel: someone one who doesn’t understand Hebrew will have a hard time following what’s really going on here. And I assume that from an average American’s POV Poland is even more obscure (fewer individuals who maintain close ties to both countries, plus the no-Jews-no-news maxim).
The other reason may be that the situation in Poland is still unfolding – i.e. there are literally no news, at least not yet. In Israel it’s the other way around: too much news, all the time – blink and you miss it. But that’s a whole different subject. I may well be wrong about this re Poland and things may be moving fast over there as well – but I have no way of knowing, because of language.
Just my proverbial $0.02.
All that said and to echo what Paul never tires of pointing out: the default reading must be that the EU is not on the side of the angels in this.
Add that to my balance of $0.00, and I’m up to $0.02, which is a decided improvement! So, thanks.
🙂
BTW, I forgot all about Visegrad24. I believe that Stefan Tompson has a Polish background. Problem is, they try to cover everything (although mostly Europe, UK and the ME). Currently and as pertinent to Poland, it’s all about that “right-wing” shooter in Krakow…