We are developing the social individualist meta-context for the future. From the very serious to the extremely frivolous... lets see what is on the mind of the Samizdata people.

Samizdata, derived from Samizdat /n. - a system of clandestine publication of banned literature in the USSR [Russ.,= self-publishing house]

Samizdata quote of the day – Cancel that Oxfam subscription, right now

Oxfam started out as famine relief – a good, Godly, righteous thing to be doing. Get food to the starving – bonzer.

Then two things happen. One, we find out that shipping food to the starving – except in the most obvious cases of outright famine – isn’t really the way to do it. Because that bankrupts all the farmers for the next year, we make the problem permanent. Instead, we should ship money to poor people so they can buy food.

This requires fewer bureaucrats in aid agencies.

– Tim Worstall

16 comments to Samizdata quote of the day – Cancel that Oxfam subscription, right now

  • NickM

    Oxford. The oldest university in the country. JRRT and boating and spires and all that.

    And then this.

    I mean for fuck’s sake!

  • Fraser

    Poverty has fallen from 27% to 2.6% from 2011 to today. That is a remarkable achievement in fifteen years.

    One of the problems with cause charities is that when the achieve their cause they are left with a big organization and nothing to do with it. This is why, for example, March of Dimes a charity set up in the 1930s to help combat infant polio is still going strong despite the fact the polio of all kinds has basically been gone for fifty years. I’d also say that I think it is no coincidence that when gay people got the right to marry (and to be clear — as they damn well should have done) around the world, that we saw the invention of this new cause and rapid rise of intersexuality and trans rights.

    What is left as the source of poverty is really the kleptocracies that populate various parts of the world. I often think that instead of shipping food we should be shipping AR-15s. However, Africa does not have a good history of the people rising up to form liberal democracies, they tend to just kill each other as happened so horribly in Rwanda and is currently happening in South Africa and Zimbabwe.

    However, the world is on the propinquity of massive technological change, and we will all have to see how that affects these situations.

    [*] BTW, regarding March of Dimes, although polio, once a scourge, has been almost eliminated, the anti vax movement has ticked things up and so there are some cases of polio appearing again even in western countries. The dishonestly regarding Covid vaccines has rolled down the hill to cause broader vaccine skepticism, which is a very dangerous thing. And this is one of the horrible consequences of science and medicine lying to us — we stop believing the good with the bad. mRNA vaccines have the potential to save millions of lives if we take them out of the realm of politics and put them back into the realm of science and medicine.

  • Paul Marks

    In a case of natural disaster there may be no food locally to be bought – in which case sending food makes sense.

    But not via Oxfam – which is an organisation with a leftist political and cultural agenda.

  • Mr Ed

    I understand that Oxfam started off in WW2 campaigning to send food to Nazi-occupied Greece.

    I think that’s as much as you need to know about it, you can guess the rest. The English upper-middle class Orwell described as preferring to have been caught stealing from the poor box in church than to be seen standing for ‘God Save the King’?

  • jgh

    Mr Ed: and their modern descendants are campaigning to send food and other resources to Gaza. That would be like sending resources to the Nazis during WW2.

  • Fraser

    @jgh
    Mr Ed: and their modern descendants are campaigning to send food and other resources to Gaza. That would be like sending resources to the Nazis during WW2.

    Bullshit. There is a gigantic amount of suffering from ordinary people who have nothing to do with terrorism there. Horrific suffering. It is an extremely difficult situation that I think Israel is trying to be generous with as they continue bombing. For example, Israel has just conducted a large vaccination campaign there. But don’t doubt there is immense suffering of innocent people there, and trying to relieve that suffering is a noble goal.

    I am reminded of that aphorism from Nietzsche, “Beware that, when fighting monsters, you yourself do not become a monster”.

  • Marius

    There is a gigantic amount of suffering from ordinary people who have nothing to do with terrorism there.

    I doubt the population of Dresden was 100% Nazi. You don’t beat genocidal maniacs by sending them food parcels.

    Aid which goes to Gaza enriches Hamas. The 2023 atrocity and its resistance to Israel’s retaliation was funded by aid.

  • NickM

    Aid sent to Gaza (whatever the intent) enables Hamas. It means Gazans can scrape by (just) on the largesse of Hamas.

    Fraser,
    I have stated here before that the rise of some very strange “identity” campaigns is because to all intents and porpoises (do dolphins also count?) after LGB rights were established (and, perhaps more importantly established pretty much without that much controversy) the activist class simply needed a new hill to fight on. And trans was that hill.

    Apparently, in the UK, you shall soon be able to identify as a cat. Julia is giving me a nasty look. Julia does identify as a cat because she is actually a cat. Isn’t a human identifying as a cat “cultural appropriation”?

  • Paul Marks

    Marius and NickM – yes.

    And Israel’s weakness (and it has been weak) had increased, not reduced, civilian casualties.

    “We must warm people before we bomb a position – otherwise civilians will be hurt” – that means the enemy move from position to position and you have to bomb more and more places till whole areas are destroyed. As for the civilians, the woman and children, often Hamas and the Islamic groups do not allow them to leave buildings that are to be bombed – even whilst they themselves leave via underground tunnels.

    So a campaign that should have lasted a couple of weeks – has dragged on for more than three years.

    Even after all these years the Israeli establishment has got-a-clue about Islam – they do not understand it.

    They, the Israeli establishment, assume that everyone, deep down, is the same – and all people are NOT the same.

    President Trump, and his advisers (whether it be Secretary of State and National Security Director Rubio or Vice President Vance) do not understand Islam either.

    They have a “Star Trek” view of war – you fight in order to make the other side come to a settlement, “make a deal”.

    Followers of Islam, such as Hamas (but also other groups – both Sunni and Shia) do not think like that – their view of war is totally different. For example, they sincerly believe that if they or their families are killed fighting infidels they will have eternal bliss in Paradise. Just as they believe that torturing infidels to death, in the most degrading ways possible (for example forcing them to commit sexual acts on their own family members) is a morally GOOD thing to do – as infidels who resist deserve not just death, but the worst forms of ritual humilation before death.

    “They can not really believe that” – they do believe that.

    New York property developers or businessmen who spent their formative years in Philadelphia do not fully understand this mentality.

    All the pundits say that President Trump is going to lose today (even though he is not on the ballot – the election is really about him, most voters know NOTHING about the Democrats they are voting for – and would be utterly horrified if they knew what monsters these Dems are) – and that means the United States will go down the same plughole that the United Kingdom is going down. It did not need to be this way – the campaign against the Islamic Republic of Iran regime could have been won in a few weeks – instead it has dragged on for more than eight months, and without victory.

    The “talks and deals” brigade had control – and that includes President Trump himself.

  • Paul Marks

    I watched some voters being interviewed – they came out with the standard (standardly demented) Democrat Talking Points that the media (and the churches – them to) have been pushing.

    “Reduce gas prices and make things more affordable” – in reality all the Democrat policies are designed to INCREASE fuel prices, and to increase prices generally – but the voters do not know this.

    “We have to come together – unity, civility” – in reality voting Democrat will mean savage conflict between the President and Congress, more Impeachment Trials and so on.

    “Education is being restricted, children are being prevented knowing things” – the “things” that some (a few) States are trying to stop being pushed on young children, are the most bizarre perversions – including the child sexual mutilation “Trans” cult, but, yet again, the voters do not know this. At least not the voters I have seen interviewed by the media.

    It is all like watching train crash – like the recent one in Spain that killed so many people.

    I have no desire to watch such things – I have had enough.

  • NickM

    Paul,
    The remarkable thing is that Hamas have been totally honest about not wanting women and children in their extensive tunnel network (I think it is slightly larger than the Moscow Subway*). They have said all that blood is on Israel’s (and a bit wider) hands. They cynically wanted children to die. That is vile.

    Moreover this has not been challenged by the media. At all.

    Would Hamas even understand Aragorn’s insistence at The Hornburg? “Is there no way for the women and children to get out?” Maybe, but they wouldn’t act on it. They want as much slaughter of their own children because it makes good TV. And it means more aid which means the Hamas(h)ites can concentrate on genocide** rather than actually creating a reasonable country. Gaza could be great. The beaches look magnificent and I do like the Eastern Med for holidays. And as a small nation they could have “interesting” tax laws. Think Jersey with better weather. But, no. All they do is hate and blame. Hamas has done vastly more damage to Gaza than the IDF ever could.

    It is easier to destroy than to build. And it is much easier when that gets you foreign aid.

    *The effort, the money (from the “international community”), the undoubted talent and skill that went into that (I mean Gaza, not Moscow) which could have been used for anything else is tragic.
    **Ironically by claiming “genocide” against themselves. “When I use a word,” Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, “it means just what I choose it to mean—neither more nor less.”

  • Tanuki

    Oxfam isn’t one of my favourite NGOs, their attitude to third-world* ‘development’ – particularly in agriculture – is abhorrent: they seemingly reject the use of genetic modification, synthetic fertilisers, fossil fuels, pesticides, instead promoting the continuation of low-input [apart, that is, from the input of large amounts of back-breaking human labour] low-yield subsistence-farming.

    It’s almost as if the last 200 years of agricultural advancement is something they want to deny. I guess they need to keep their client-base poor.

    *are we allowed to use that term these days?

  • IrishOtter49

    I have no desire to watch such things – I have had enough.

    Good. Does that mean you’ll quit writing about them?

  • Paul Marks

    IrishOtter49 – do you have to be ass, all the time? Could you at least try NOT to be ass?

    The election results proved me to be correct (I wish I had NOT been correct) – but, as you are an ass, you do not care about that.

    NickM – the media I understand, they are propagandists, the truth does not matter to them – only their agenda matters to them.

    What I do not understand is the government of Israel – with their demented policy of endless delays, and warnings which do not save civilians, but do allow the enemy to relocate – again and again. Mr Ed warned me in 2023 – he guessed that the Israelis would not go hard and finish the war quickly, that they would drag things out (with endless regulations and delays) and destroy, by prolonging the conflict, what international support they started with. But I was too stupid (too dumb) to believe him – I could not believe the Israeli government would behave like that, but he was correct – they behaved exactly as he predicted.

    But then I do not understand the Trump Administration either.

    To allow the campaign against the Islamic Republic of Iran regime (which could have been over in a few weeks) to drag on for more than eight months was insane – utterly insane.

    Alternatively important advisers to the President WANTED to lose the midterm elections – and delayed military victory in order to achieve electoral defeat.

    However, with Mr “talks and deals” as President a conspiracy was not really needed – his actions are in accord with his character as a businessman, a deal maker.

    The policy of endless delays in the military campaign has led to electoral disaster – although (yes) almost half the American population are indoctrinated by the left to start with.

  • Stonyground

    “I guess they need to keep their client-base poor.”

    Of course they do. Otherwise they would have to find another cause in order to keep the money flowing in. It was mentioned in an earlier post that organisations that have completed the job that they set out to do don’t just pack up and leave, they have to extend their remit to something else.

  • bloke in spain

    Oxford. The oldest university in the country. JRRT and boating and spires and all that.

    If England’s oldest cesspit was still in operation it would be an improvement.

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>