We are developing the social individualist meta-context for the future. From the very serious to the extremely frivolous... lets see what is on the mind of the Samizdata people.

Samizdata, derived from Samizdat /n. - a system of clandestine publication of banned literature in the USSR [Russ.,= self-publishing house]

1st Amendment riots in Iran

Glenn Reynolds pointed out an article in today’s New York Times on the 4th day of student riots in Iran.

What? You haven’t heard? Presumably that’s because the news media thinks we’re more interested in whom is buggering whom in Buckingham than in events of real import? Yes. Of course. That must be it.

The Iranian government has given a sentence of death by hanging to an academic, Hashem Aghajari, for what Americans would call an exercise of his First Amendment rights. If profs in the USA think they are losing those rights simply because someone criticises them, they should consider Iran, where the State can make you lose your head instead of just your temper.

The student protests have spread to other cities and seem likely to continue unless the medieval mullahs stomp on them, an action which would just polarize any remaining fence sitters. The Iranian students are living proof there is a liberal, tolerant 21st Century face to Islam crying out for escape from the rule of fundamentalist fruitcakes.

News media everywhere should be pushing this story with as much alacrity as possible. No reasonable person wants to see blanket hatreds grow. This is precisely what al Qaeda wants. If they have any strategy, it is to bring about the war of civilizations in hopes they can win by expending more lives than we in the civilized world have a stomach for. They are not sufficiently versed in history to understand how terribly mistaken they are or exactly how apocalyptic such a war would be for all… but most especially for them.

We must let the average guy on the street know there are Muslims out there who are just like him or her; people who want to live their lives, worship in their faith, exercise basic liberties… and most importantly, allow others to do the same.

My feelings of hope for Iran are not new. Even in the days immediately following September 11th I told friends Iran is different. There is hope for it. It was never as crazy a place as the rest of the Medieval East; it has an educated populace which understands what a civil society is about. One way or the other they will find their way out of the swamp Khomeini led them into.

I do not think their own government is quite so evil as others in the region. I do not believe Iranians will sacrifice their own children to the past and there is no other path but that of massive and violent repression if they are to block reform.

If I knew an appropriate Muslim phrase (other than Inshallah, which is a bit weak for what I wish them) I would say it for those young Iranians who seek the blessings of Liberty.

I guess “good luck and godspeed” will have to serve.

3 comments to 1st Amendment riots in Iran

  • Have y’all read about the sentence he was given?

  • Reid

    Yes, there are good Muslims but, you may be overemphasizing it here. It appears that quite a lot of Iranians are, in fact, fed up with Islam. A lot see it as the religion of the coarse and brutish Arab conquerors who destroyed their enlightened empire. Some are discussing a revival of Zoroastrianism. As best I can tell, reading about it half a world away, most want a secular state.

    Muslims are not robots, and Islam is not something encoded in their DNA. I am waiting to see what happens when the chains are broken.

  • Reid

    BTW: Insh’allah is Arabic. Here are some good Farsi phrases I picked up off an Iranian website:

    Marg bar Taleban e Iran
    (Death to the Iranian Taliban)
    yek mamlekat, yek dowlat, aan ham beh ray-e mellat
    (One nation, one government, by the vote of the people)
    aazaadiyeh andisheh bi matbuaat nemisheh
    (There is no freedom of thought without the press)