We are developing the social individualist meta-context for the future. From the very serious to the extremely frivolous... lets see what is on the mind of the Samizdata people.

Samizdata, derived from Samizdat /n. - a system of clandestine publication of banned literature in the USSR [Russ.,= self-publishing house]

Rats in a sack, ctd

There is a certain grim satisfaction in reading this story, on how one UK government minister – seen as a potential future Labour leader – has announced, without telling Gordon Brown, that the case for compulsory ID cards has been scrapped.

Of course, the real issue remains that even without compulsory ID cards, we have a state database on every person in this country; and the aggregation of data about us gets more intensive, and is unlikely to be reversed regardless of the outcome of the next election. Too much money has been spent, too many corporate interests have been bought, for that to stop.

8 comments to Rats in a sack, ctd

  • Marc Sheffner

    First they tell us there will be a national ID card, then they tell us there won’t be.
    Either way,
    we have no say
    we’re in the sway
    of our lords and masters.
    Let us pray…

  • Is this the guy who told us we need them and will want them and that he never scrapped them?

    http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/libertycentral/2009/jul/02/identity-cards-fraud-cost

  • mike

    “grim satisfaction”

    Grim? Yes. Satisfaction? No: my personal opinion.

    That mere voluntary receipt of an ID card is reported as a significant political development just goes to show the distance between any idea of personal liberty for British subjects and the U-bend down which it has long since been flushed.

    Reading the Telegraph every day must be like going on a diet of aftershave.

  • watcher in the dark

    I for one welcome our new overlords, and look forward to that golden day when on the steps of No 10, one of NuLab’s jolly, affable replacements for Kim Il McBroon will wave his voluntary ID card at us like… like a certain Mr Chamberlain and that famous piece of paper.

  • Nuke Gray!

    Well, i think Britain is leading the way in the open society stakes! You not only know who the head of your ‘Secret’ Services are, but where to find them on Holidays! It must be true- honest people have nothing to hide!

  • ThousandsOfMilesAway

    As pointed out elsewhere, Labour are clearing the decks of troublesome policy issues in advance of the election.

    While the abandonment of compulsory ID cards is to be welcomed, we obviously have to exercise caution in trusting a word these fkers say, especially in proximity to an election.

    But just have a look at the comments on the Johnson Guardian article quoted above (and posted about here also) – there is no way ID cards have legs in the current climate – and people (well the internet commentariat at least) seem to be well aware that the real danger is from the database and the general aggregation of personal data on us by the state. These are reasons to be guardedly positive.

  • ThousandsOfMilesAway

    As pointed out elsewhere, Labour are clearing the decks of troublesome policy issues in advance of the election.

    While the abandonment of compulsory ID cards is to be welcomed, we obviously have to exercise caution in trusting a word these fkers say, especially in proximity to an election.

    But just have a look at the comments on the Johnson Guardian article quoted above (and posted about here also) – there is no way ID cards have legs in the current climate – and people (well the internet commentariat at least) seem to be well aware that the real danger is from the database and the general aggregation of personal data on us by the state. These are reasons to be guardedly positive.

  • Whether we have ID cards or not big brother is always watching. They are filthy rats and liars