Matt Ridley writes, “The plot to discredit the Covid lab leak theory was a crime against science”
Jay Bhattacharya, head of the National Institutes of Health, has written to Nature Medicine journal demanding a “formal, independent investigation” into why a key scientific paper misled the world about the virus causing Covid, and concealed the contributions made by three senior scientists to commissioning, reviewing and editing the paper.
In a career as a science writer that spans more than four decades, I have never seen an alleged case of scientific malpractice as influential. Like many others I have called for the paper to be retracted. Twice, the editor of the journal, Joao Monteiro, has been sent letters from numerous leading scientists demanding an investigation or retraction of the misleading paper. He has ignored us.
I know the paper entitled “Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2” was misleading because I was among those misled. At the time I sat on the science and technology select committee of the House of Lords and we were conducting an inquiry to try to understand this new virus threatening all our lives. The possibility that it had been accidentally released from a laboratory, if true, would have significant implications for the public-health response: a virus marinaded in human tissues in a laboratory for weeks would be far more infectious than one newly arrived from bats.
Parliamentary colleagues were asking me what I thought. To my shame, I told them a lab leak could be ruled out. I did so based almost entirely on the authority of this one paper. That very phrase “ruled out” appeared in the press announcement of the paper from the institution where the lead author, Kristian Andersen, worked. The article itself left no room for doubt: “we do not believe that any type of laboratory based scenario is plausible… our analyses clearly show that SARS-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct.”
That these words appeared in Nature Medicine gave them a stamp of authority, or so I believed. The paper was subsequently viewed millions of times and cited in thousands of academic papers. The journal and the authors of the paper therefore had a special responsibility not to allow themselves to be misled. Yet we now know that Proximal Origin’s arguments were flawed and released Slack messages and emails show several of its authors were expressing exactly the opposite opinion in private both before, during and after publication. They still thought a lab leak was “friggin likely”, in the words of Andersen.
Worse than all that, congressional investigations have uncovered records strongly indicating that three of the most senior medical scientists in the world, Francis Collins (Bhattacharya’s predecessor as head of the National Institutes of Health), Anthony Fauci (head of National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Diseases) and Jeremy Farrar (head of the Wellcome Trust) had not only seen the paper before publication, but – according to a House Select Subcommittee report – had prompted its authors to write it in the first place, had reviewed it and even suggested alterations in wording. Fauci referred to the paper from the White House podium, giving no hint of his own role in it.
Science requires honest admission of error. Ridley’s done his. Now the authors and undisclosed funders of this paper need to step up, alongside the editor of Nature Medicine, Joao Monteiro. If they do not, we are entitled to conclude that they were deliberately lying.




Leave a Reply