Comments on Samizdata quote of the day

Many in Washington and Whitehall would do well do remember this.

Sadly, they don't.


Posted by M. Thompson at November 2, 2009 12:54 AM

Perfect!


Posted by Verity at November 2, 2009 01:43 AM

I think that liberty is a tool by which we can seek our happiness in this world. to be free to do something is what we usually want, or sometimes it is put as freedom from an intrusive law. Having liberty does not make you happy, but having a goal, and being free to achieve your goal, does bring happiness.


Posted by Nuke Gray at November 2, 2009 02:07 AM

The only freedom, is freedom from other people.


Posted by cjf at November 2, 2009 04:07 AM

Freedom from attack from other people - from having them violate either your body or your goods.

Of course government does not promise this freedom - if you are attacked you have no legal case against the police for failing to prevent the attack (no matter how much money you are forced to pay in taxes).

A just government (yes I know "a unicorn") confines itself to trying to defend the bodies and goods of people (the principle of justice - see Bastiat's "The Law"), but even a just government will not always succeed in this protection, or in punishing violators.

Nor should "its the government's job" mean that people should not defend themselves and their familes (by an means necessary) or that they should not come to the aid of other people who are underattack. Or not seek the punishment of criminals have have violated people.

Even if someone is a total stranger the punishment of their murderers is still a moral duty.

In a city this may be best done by reporting them to the police and testifying against them in a court of law.

But out in the wilds (where is, in practice, no government - in various times and places) one may have to hunt down the robbers and murderers one's self (with what allies one can gather).

Not so "Wild West" as one might guess.

Indeed up to 1856 there were counties in England that had no government police - the magistrate (unpaid himself) would call upon ordinary people to help him hunt down the guilty and bring them to justice.

And even in the early 20th century it was normal for British people to own firearms - and for the police NOT to have them.

There are several cases of police (even in London) facing armed criminals and calling upon armed members of the public (who happened to have been passing by) to help them.

Without freedom the moral development of society is crushed.

People remain infants - forbidden to bare arms and looking to government to meet all their needs.


Posted by Paul Marks at November 2, 2009 11:09 AM

For a very long time, I thought Freedom was the desirable state of being, every-one desired. Now based upon the huge tolerance for socialism, I!m wondering just how many of the 300 million plus in this country, really want to be free. Obviously a large number prefer the socialist nanny state to the self-responsibility of personal freedom and private property Rights.

Thanks

Anne Cleveland
octogenariansblog.com


Posted by Anne Cleveland at November 2, 2009 04:24 PM

It may sound strange, but may I recommend reading Herzen on the Immediate value of liberty.


Posted by RRS at November 2, 2009 06:05 PM

OOPS: Clicked too soon

There is also Isaiah Berlin's Four Essays on Liberty (Oxford Press- 1969) which includes his rather well known Two Concepts of Liberty (his Oxford inaugeral address of 1958);
positive and negative liberty (simplified as "Freedom from and Freedom to").


Posted by RRS at November 2, 2009 06:19 PM

I think Anne Cleveland has it about right. Most people would be happy if their "freedom" extended only as far as choosing whether to watch professional wrestling or Monday Night Football. Real freedom terrifies them; they want someone to tell them what to do and when to do it. Which is why democratic self-government is likely to prove a relatively short-lived experiment; we are currently proving that, as a species, we can't handle it.


Posted by Laird at November 3, 2009 05:21 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?


Enter anti-spambot Turing code:





Select some text and click this to format it as a quote Make the selected text bold Make the selected text italic Add a web link


Basic html active.

Alas, but for obscure reasons Mac and some Linux users cannot use push-button formatting options and have to use basic html manually. Revealed forthwith are the mysteries of basic Html:

<strong>This text in-between is bold</strong>

<em>This text is in italics</em>

And
<blockquote>This is a quote</blockquote>
Remember to close your opened tags as such: <tag> tagged text and closing </tag> and we promise you will get out of here alive.

For adding links, either use the link URL button on the toolbar or enter your code by hand in the following format:
<a href="http://www.your_link.com">your link text or description here</a>

Your e-mail address will NOT be displayed.

You are a guest on private property and we reserve the right to delete anything we want to. Have fun but please be civil and succinct. Blogroaches will be persecuted, not to mention IP banned. Be polite or prepare to be deleted.

Long third party quotes or articles will also be deleted... so just link to articles you think are germane to your comment, do not quote the whole bloody thing.

And finally, please do not post using different names to agree with yourself, it will only get your comments deleted and banned.