Friday
Allow me to put it another way, instead of scientists, these people were hedge managers, and they were found by an inquiry, run by fund managers and bankers, of not being involved in insider trading, but being part of a fan club. Moreover, though the figures they published for investors were misleading, the investors could have obtained the raw data and worked out that they were being sold a lemon on their own.
Would you be so forgiving?
- A commenter challenges George Monbiot on the subject of the Russell "Inquiry", which found evidence of a failure to by communicate, but which didn't find anything wrong with "climate science" on account of it not trying to. Recycled by "James P" in his comment here.

And so… these Learned Men, having Inquir’d into the Case for the Opposition, discover’d that the Opposition had no Case and were Devoid of Merit, which was what they Suspected all along, and they arriv’d at this Happy Conclusion by the most Economical and Nice of all Methods of Enquiry, which was that they did not Invite the Opposition to confuse Matters by Participating in the Discussion.
http://hotair.com/archives/2010/07/08/wonderful-news-on-climate-change/
Posted by Frank S at July 9, 2010 01:39 PM
I forgot to mention that I found the above quotation in a comment on the Bishop Hill blog:
http://bishophill.squarespace.com/blog/2010/7/8/acton-on-the-sap.html
Posted by Frank S at July 9, 2010 01:43 PM





