The jewel in the crown of Samizdata.net
A blog for people with a critically rational individualist perspective. We are developing the social individualist meta-context for the future. From the very serious to the extremely frivolous... lets see what is on the mind of the Samizdata people.

Samizdata, derived from Samizdat /n. a system of clandestine publication of banned literature in the USSR
[Russ.,= self-publishing house]
There is much to find for those who look
We are not alone
Made possible by...
 
May 23, 2007
Wednesday
 
 
Comedy horror documentary
Guy Herbert (London)  Arts & Entertainment • Civil liberty/regulation • UK affairs

OK, I am biassed. NO2ID gets a credit on this film. But having been to a contributors' screening last night, I think you could do worse than drag any friends or relations who are complacent about Britain being 'a free country' along to Taking Liberties (since 1997) when it opens on June 8th. If you have a black sense of humour, you will laugh.

Not much in the film will come as news to Samizdata readers, and to get anything like a coherent story out of so much material it has had to simplify, rather. But I was very pleasantly surprised that in doing so it avoids falling into the usual human-rightist traps of equating liberty with leftism. Teeters on the edge occasionally, perhaps. The sequence on Guantanamo is a little too long, and I think unbalances the section on the Blair regime's complicity in torture. But there are few tendentious statements, and in most ways it is a conservative polemic. If there are heroes on screen they are mild-mannered middle-class pacifists. The off-screen heroes are Winston Churchill and the common law courts.

The points are made gently and methodically, ticking off, one by one, the broad civil liberties supposedly assured by the Human Rights Act, but actually removed by the same government that made such a fanfare of its respect for "our way of life". Boiling the story down from a vast mass of information they could have included makes it very solidly founded. This is polemic, but the antithesis of Michael-Moore-style, concocted illustration of an artificial thesis. I spotted only very few factual errors, and I am an awful nitpicking wonk, as you all know.

What will stay with me, however, is what I had not seen before. Footage of lots of officious political policing and show of official force. Those who think we are softies whining about nothing will no doubt say that actually this just illustrates we are in no danger, Britain is still a healthy democracy (whatever that means). But is it really better to be smothered with a feather pillow than publicly garotted?

PS - Like a lot of small films this starts out in a few screens and hopes for a rolling release, so it is desperately sensitive to opening receipts. If you do go to see it when it opens, you increase the chance that others will get a chance do so too.

Comments

Perhaps copies should be provided free to every school.

Best regards


Posted by Nigel Sedgwick at May 23, 2007 02:03 PM

Yeah like that's going to happen, I would love to see this film at my local art cinema (the Odious wouldn't touch it) but failing that I'll gladly pay for a download.


Posted by mandrill at May 23, 2007 03:13 PM

I'm sure your local arthouse welcomes suggestions, mandrill


Posted by guy herbert at May 23, 2007 03:24 PM

I'd agree with Mandrill - a paid for download would get the film to a much wider audience.


Posted by James Marwood at May 23, 2007 05:44 PM
is brought to the screen by the producer of Michael Moore’s Fahrenheit 9/11 and Bowling for Columbine

sounds like one to miss then. the film maker is clearly a leftist


Posted by ragingnick at May 24, 2007 09:48 PM

ragingnick,

I assume you never go in a bookshop in case all those leftist writers and publishers get you.

There is a distinction between a film-maker and a producer that may be eluding you; and a further one between the views of the creator and the value of the work.

If you are only going to listen to people who pass a purity test, then you are easy meat for manipulation by anyone claiming the politically correct authority. If you are among those who feel that only people who agree with them ought to have liberty, then any film about civil liberties is not really for you.

In endorsing this film, I'm not saying that I agree with all the beliefs of everyone who features in it.

I don't agree with most of them. One group of protestors that appears has particularly irritated me in the past with its self-righteous inability to see other people might have other points of view. One of the lawyers shown is famous for theories that I think are nonsense on stilts.

But people are entitled to be wrong. The political use of state power to punish dissent, to bully - and worse - those who are minor violators of norms or arbitrarily deemed "bad", affects everyone who is not determined to be a fawning follower of authority wherever authority should lead.


Posted by guy herbert at May 25, 2007 06:37 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?


Enter anti-spambot Turing code:





Select some text and click this to format it as a quote Make the selected text bold Make the selected text italic Add a web link


Basic html active.

Alas, but for obscure reasons Mozilla, Mac and Linux users shall not harness to power of the push-button formatting options and shall therefore compose basic html with their bare hands. Yet Mozilla, Mac and Linux users shall not fear, for we shall reveal forthwith the mysteries of Basic Html:

<strong>This text in-between is bold</strong>

<em>This text is in italics</em>

And
<blockquote>This is a quote</blockquote>
Remember to close your opened tags as such: <tag> tagged text and closing </tag> and we promise you will get out of here alive.

For adding links, either use the link URL button on the toolbar or enter your code by hand in the following format:
<a href="http://www.your_link.com">your link text or description here</a>

Movable Type's anti-spambot e-mail address protection is enabled.

You are a guest on private property. Have fun but please be civil and succinct. Blogroaches will be persecuted, not to mention IP banned.

Long third party quotes or articles will also be deleted... so just link to articles you think are germane to your comment, don't quote the whole bloody thing.