We are developing the social individualist meta-context for the future. From the very serious to the extremely frivolous... lets see what is on the mind of the Samizdata people.

Samizdata, derived from Samizdat /n. - a system of clandestine publication of banned literature in the USSR [Russ.,= self-publishing house]

England in the Rugby World Cup Final – and France hung out to dry

I should have had a good brag about this well before now, but at least the delay has given the Guardian the time to translate the comments in the French and Australian sporting press about it all – it all being the fact that, last Sunday morning London time, England beat France 24-7 in the second semi-final of the Rugby World Cup, in Sydney, and are through to next Saturday’s Final against Australia.

This was something of a surprise to some, and some included me. France had looked terrific all through the early rounds, while England had stuttered against lowlier opposition. But when it came to le crunch England were up for it and France crumpled.

The twin nemeses of France were the two Ws, the Weather, and Wilkinson. After a warm and sunny week during which the French practised their fluent running and passing game, the actual game was played at a far lower temperature and in drenching rain and horribly gusting wind. As Le Parisien put it (translated for the Guardian):

Repeated errors, lack of control, appaling place kicking – on D Day, les Bleus blew it. We will no doubt be speaking for years to come of the dreadful weather that accompanied this match but it alone cannot exonerate the French team. In the pouring rain, the wretched English hung us out to dry.

France found themselves relying far more than they would have wanted on the kicking, in open play and at goal, of their young fly half Frédéric Michalak, who until Sunday could do no wrong. But on Sunday, he managed just two points, when he converted an early French try, and he then went on to miss four kicks at goal. His tactical kicking in open play was, if anything, ever more disappointing. Often French kicks that were supposed to be straight ahead, instead went straight up in the air.

England fly half Jonny Wilkinson, meanwhile, kicked far better in open play, as did the man next to him, Mike Catt. Like Michalak, Wilkinson missed a few penalty kicks, but in extreme contrast to Michalak he landed five. Equally important, he also kicked three ‘drop’ goals, as they’re called. Drop goals, where you half-volley kick the ball while on the move, instead of kicking it after placing it on the ground, are hard to bring off in perfect weather and with no pressure on you. For Wilkinson to break the England international drop goal record by kicking no less than three of these things, in a World Cup semi-final in weather than was downright vile, was extraordinary. So it was Michalak 2 Wilkinson (and therefore England because England never managed a try) 24.

The French experience in this tournament put me in mind of that line in Top Gun, where flying instructor Michael Ironside says to Tom Cruise something along the lines of: “That was some of the greatest flying I’ve ever seen, right up to the part where you got killed.”

I’ve been doing occasional pieces about this tournament for Scott Wickstein’s Ubersportingpundit group blog, and that Top Gun thing was a line I’ve already used there. If you want to know more of how I’ve been seeing it all, go read that stuff. Writing it has been for me what the Americans call a learning experience, truly.

In other words, mostly I’ve been getting it wrong. I said that the New Zealand All Blacks would beat Australia in the other semi-final, and like everyone, I thought France had been looking great, but not England. Until last Sunday. But next Saturday morning it will be host nation Australia (victors against the All Blacks by 22-10 in the first semi-final) against England.

So far, England have scored hardly any tries, except against minnows in two of their opening group matches. Every time they’ve won against medium-ranking opposition amidst barrages of Wilkinson penalty kicks, the Aussie press has yelled: “Is that all you’ve got?”, and: “Boring.” I and every England fan would love it if England could run in half a dozen tries next Saturday and win with style. But if at the end of it England win, and the Aussies are still asking if that’s all England have got and calling them boring, when what England have actually got is the Rugby World Cup, I for one will be very happy.

Nobody really knows what will happen. Most, like me, having been chastened by their wrong predictions for the semi-finals. If England play at their very best, they should just about shade it. If. But, they’re good at games, those Aussies.

As to what it might mean if England were to win, well … let’s win it first, eh?

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedInShare on TumblrShare on RedditShare on Google+Share on VK

9 comments to England in the Rugby World Cup Final – and France hung out to dry

  • R C Dean

    The twin nemeses of France were the two Ws, the Weather, and Wilkinson.

    What, was the weather only bad on the French side of the field?

  • gasky

    It is the sign of a great team when they can play poorly but still win. I’m sure England would love to play expansive, free flowing rugby on Saturday, but methinks they will settle for 3-0, providing they have the 3 and Australia the nil.

    By the way, the 2003 vintage in Australia threatens to be pretty poor, judging from all the sour grapes eminating from the place.

  • I really do get pretty fed up with this wingeing about penalty kicks. You can only take a penalty kick if someone from the other side gives away a penalty ie cheats.

    Of course, the reason they give away so many penalties to England is because they know if they didn’t England would score a try.

  • Brian Micklethwait

    RC Dean

    Good point, but the weather did hurt France more than England, because their best chance of winning was with a running and passing game, which became nearly impossible in all that wetness.

    They tried it at the end, because they had to, but they couldn’t make it work.

    It didn’t help that the kind of ball they happen to be using just now is particular hard to hold on to in the wet. Apparently, the ball they used in the previous World Cup was a lot easier to cling on to when it was wet.

    It made sense for France to bet on dry weather. As I said, it had been dry all week. And it was dry for the previous game between NZ and Australia.

    There were several moments in the game when France would have been very threatening, if they hadn’t dropped the ball. In dry weather, they probably wouldn’t have dropped it, and that might have been an entirely different game.

    On the other hand, maybe England might have scored some tries too.

  • A point similar to Patrick’s:

    When the Aussies say “is that all you’ve got,” referring to Wilkinson, they’re forgetting about 50% of the game – defence.

    If the England defenders were ineffective, then a few drop goals and penalties wouldn’t win a game, would it?

    I too would love to see some tries, but part of me wouldn’t mind a 3-0 display, just to hear the Aussie whingeing and excuses.

  • Sean

    I was just happy to see the ‘doers’ in Iraq, England and Australia, put (another) one over the ‘talkers’, France and New Zealand. Also, what’s up with the French crest? A yellow chicken…how quaint.

  • aussie commentators forgetting about defence? The aussies won against NZ, and will probably win against England, because of their absolutely fantastic creativity crushing defence!

    Justin Marshall= Johnny Wilkinson? Even if not, good luck trying to kick drop goals against a pack that is moving forward!

  • The Ausies are in a bit of a panic. The one stick that they have always been able to bash the English over the head with is sport and now England have a stick too. The Ausies don’t really know how to handle that, hence all the frothing.

    Sooner or later they are going to have to realise that they actually like the English and that there are others, more worthy, of a good stick bashing.

  • I have to say that most of this frothing is ‘media driven’.

    We have been more interested in Australia with bashing New Zealand then England, actually, if the jokes coming into my in-box are any guide.